Wednesday, 12 September 2012

To Deny Our Nothingness:A Response to Contemporary Images of India in the Media


        To Deny Our Nothingness: A Response to Contemporary Images of India in the Media.
Readers will look askance at my temerity to write this article- a daring attempt to release India from the current humiliating images that the media- in particular, the electronic media -had assiduously created in the last couple of years. While the ostensible whipping boy is the Congress, followed by politicians of all hues, the images flashed on our screens are only about us, We, the Indians.
One cannot miss the overt glee in the news anchors’ almost daily litany that they have accessed new CAG reports on one scam or the other causing a loss of many lakh crores of rupees to the exchequer that would make all the preceding losses seem trifler than a peanut. Almost every Channel (barring the Government owned Doordarshan) loudly trumpets its claim for being the first to break the scam news. Indian media seems not only ubiquitous; its detective wing outperforms the investigations of the celebrated trio in CID- (the longest running crime detective series on Sony TV Channel), Pradhuyman, Abhijeet and Daya.  Nobody seems to wonder (and worry) how Media gets access to reports right under the nose of the CAG before they are tabled in the Parliament? Why such leakages- and that too- from the office of the chief Auditor of India go undetected and those who perpetrate them go scot free? Are there no CID stars in the Government to look into this open secret of quotidian leakage? No one dares to question whether it is ethical for the media to red flag reports in advance that are primarily the parliament’s privileged documents. Today’s Media has appropriated to itself the roles of CAG, CVC, CBI and the Judiciary to go hammer and tongs at all the dramatis personae of its daily soap opera SCAM. But the truth is it cannot claim credit for exposing the scams as that belongs to the CAG. Media’s scam news is by no stretch of imagination investigative journalism. It is intrusive journalism- intruding into Government offices and using underhand means to get the reports leaked to the Media. 
The term ‘scam’ is misleading as CAG reports cannot be called scams until they are examined and accepted by the PAC after it is tabled in the Parliament. CAG assists the committee during the course of investigation. None of the 22 members of the PAC is a minister in the government and conventionally PAC is headed by a member belonging to the opposition party.  The reports become scams once the findings of the CAG are endorsed by the PAC and recommended for criminal investigation. The Media clearly jumps the gun when it flashes in the Breaking News that another scam has broken. The old adage that no one is pronounced guilty unless s/he is proved to be so, is now reversed as the Media pronounces person(s) guilty till the ‘guilty’ prove their innocence. The media ups the ante on alleged scams to the extent that India has come to be seen as one huge cauldron of corruption. The government remains paralyzed as all its efforts are towards countering the damning propaganda that goes on in the Media. This is neither  to question the CAG reports –whether they are absolutely true or had erred on the side of exaggeration- nor to question the need for Government to prove its accountability. Media’s responsibility is to make public the outcome of Government’s response to the PAC and to the Parliament but not to be judgmental, leave aside jumping the gun to allege that Government is a monstrous scamster.
For the last two years this theatre of decadence has been on our news channels. Behind rampant ethical correctness, the media has launched a blitzkrieg against Indian government, politicians and businessmen alleging corruption here, there, everywhere except in its sacred space. First it was the run up to the CWG games that was marred  by rains, dengue, delay, corruption, dug up roads, dirt and filth strewn all over the city. The foreign press taking the cue from the Indian media wrote off the CWG citing Indian inefficiency to host a major sporting event. The dirty pictures flashed on the BBC website were gleefully reprinted by the Indian media to show that India lives only in her toilets. No one questioned whether this filthy reporting was the erstwhile Empire’s way of striking back! For nearly six weeks we ground our noses in muck and filth and looked gleefully at CWG as Corruption Wealth Games played in a Hall of Shame. Passively we accepted the sobriquet ‘corrupt’ for ourselves and painted our shame in all its stains!  India stinking had reached incredible proportion.
It was left to our athletes to lift India stinking into India shining during the CWG games. But even before the victory bugle sounded the Last Post, the First Post was heard to mark the start of the investigations. The euphoria of a nation’s sporting success did not last even 24 hours as reports about Games scam to the staggering sum of Rs.8000 crores started coming in. India shaming eclipsed India’s momentary hours of shining. Media went berserk with the scam story to make a Kalmadi out of every Indian.
The 2G scam was the next that dragged the UPAII into deep mire with the Media relishing the scam story to make a Raja out of both the PM and the then FM- Mr Manmohan Singh and Mr. Chidambaram as the co-architects of the spectrum allocations scam. The discussions ad nauseam in the TV studio painted the entire UPAII as corrupt, in particular Mr.Chidambaram, till the Supreme Court gave him a clean chit. Enough mudslinging had taken place inside the TV studios and in the print media to leave Chidambaram wonder if the great Indian Ocean can wash this alleged stain off his hands? Anna came and Media raised the furore beyond perceived noise decibels to tar all the PM’s men with the same brush. The Adarsh scam-milder in comparison -was followed by the Coalgate that came as a relief for the Media suffering a brief scam-free interregnum. The Media gleefully latched onto the leaked CAG reports to affirm that Indian government is for the swindlers, by the swindlers and of the swindlers. The news is coming in that the media has accessed yet another scam report by the CAG on the Indian multi-national Oil and Natural Gas Corporation.
Is this the whole truth about We, the Indians?  Media says that as a watchdog, its duty is to expose. But this is not exposition as that is the work of the CAG. Media preens itself with the prosecutor’s robe and comes out displaying leaked papers with fluorescent marking of the alleged misdeeds of the Government. The bias in reporting is too authentic not to be missed. Every scam becomes ‘the mother of all scams’ (I do not know why the feminists are not up in arms) and the present government headed by an honest PM and consisting of quite a few men of known integrity is dubbed as the government of scamsters. For the media, this is the truth and nothing but the truth. But as far as it is concerned, it is above board, even if it makes moles out of the government employees with cakes and ale. Can the media honestly own that the fourth estate is absolutely honest and all such ‘scams’ are not paid news and bought news!
The truth is corruption is not just a UPAII phenomenon. It is a global phenomenon that has ballooned up with crony capitalism. It is there in all walks of life. Even the mosquito sprayer who visits your house waits for a wad of notes before issuing a chalan that your house is the breeding place for mosquitoes. It is not a UPAII phenomenon; it was there during the NDA regime and very much before that. What is new is the electronic eye that with the sanctioned democratic latitude can see wolves everywhere with absolute impunity. Media has become the Big Brother where everyone is under its complete surveillance abusing the freedom of expression to malign everyone in the establishment. An eerie atmosphere of fear and angst pervades the government and the bureaucracy resulting in inordinate delays to formulate and implement policies without inviting the Big Brother’s bash. The current scenario is ‘if you do, you are damned; if you don’t do, you are paralyzed’. The 1990s had seen bold steps taken by Manmohan Singh to liberate economy when the Big brother had not become too big for his boots. Not that there was no corruption then, but the BB chose to turn the Nelson’s eye in the larger interest of freeing the moribund economy from the clutches of Permit-license Raj. The government was then not hamstrung by coalition compulsions and could go ahead with its reforms. No such luxury is available to Manmohan Singh today and the government has been stopped from accelerating the gains of the last decade. The UPA government of the last eight years is credited with bringing in major reforms like the RTI and RTE.  But it could not push through other reforms such as FDI in retail, insurance, aviation etc, GST,GARR etc partly due to coalition compulsion and largely due to the opposition not allowing the Parliament to function. The Coalgate has recently paralyzed the Parliament but the Media by trial goes on where media functions within the precincts of the TV studios as the defacto opposition part. The truth is one Kalamadi or one Rajah does not make the entire cabinet. No doubt, the summer of discontent of 2010-12 is too true to be washed away. But Media has revelled in presenting a theatre of the Absurd that has made every Indian ashamed of his lineage and democratic inheritance. As a citizen of India, I feel angst and humiliation when newspapers and the electronic media in the name of freedom of expression indulge in vilification of the state without any sense of proportion. For all their self righteous talk that ‘no one shall rein us, we will ourselves rein in,’ the anti-establishment tirade the media resorts to make me wonder if we are deceptive recipients of paid news.
We have also seen how Indian Media felt highly vindicated when the NYT and Washington Post joined the media chorus in flaying the PM as an underachiever and a tragic figure. The irony is that the Media does not understand the meaning of Tragedy. Tragedy is defined as a colossal waste of the human potential. The tragic figure at the end rises up in the esteem of the audience when against all tragic catastrophes, he walks high, morally and spiritually triumphant. If Manmohan Singh is a tragic figure, let us salute him. Time will tell who were responsible in hampering the PM from his honest efforts to deny us, Indians, our nothingness and the role of media in denying us our dignity and worth as democratic citizens of India.






is

Friday, 31 August 2012

Musings on Teachers Day


Musings on Teachers Day
I have been a teacher for well over four decades and I share the perception with my fellow teachers that we are a unique breed. We are seemingly ubiquitous though we are noticed only once a year on Teachers Day that commemorates the birthday of the Teacher among teachers--Sarvepalli Radhakrishnan. During this week every year, we read and listen to the varied views and comments by leading academicians and omnipresent seminarists on “what ails our Indian education system". The consensual agreement among all of them is to make learning less burdensome so that children and young men and women learn better and enjoy the process of learning. These are words, words and words- empty of content and intent (typical of our garrulous race that is known to relish the sound of its own voice)- but no one has come forward with a concrete proposal as to how to make learning enjoyable except to suggest training workshops in pedagogy borrowed from Western practices. There is a sizeable section among the educationists who seek an alternative in following our own Gurukul system of education endorsing Guru-shishya parampara without answering the question where to find the Gurus in adequate numbers to educate our teeming millions! The more patriotic among our seminarists look wistfully back to historical times with a wishful dream of making India the new Nalanda and Ujjain while dreaming of the 21st century India as a Knowledge hub or a Centre of learning. One can have no quarrels with such nostalgia, but the unanswered question remains as how to reach that pinnacle of excellence that was the pride of our ancient seats of learning.
Albert Einstein, speaking about tradition and knowledge said: “the wonderful things you learn in schools and colleges are the work of many generations produced by enthusiastic effort and infinite labour... and all this is put into your hands as your inheritance in order that you may receive it, honour it, add to it and one day faithfully hand it over to your children.” Unfortunately we as educators have failed to pass our inheritance to our younger generation. We have forgotten how we were schooled and how we learnt our lessons. In those days, with no computer or calculator to our aid, we were made to learn multiplication tables from one to sixteen ending with sixteen into sixteen. The currency in those days was of three denominations- rupee, anna and paisa with 16 annas making a rupee and 12 paise making an anna and 192 paise making a rupee. We learnt to make the addition and subtraction with reference to these three denominations by mental calculations- at times even  converting fractions of rupees and annas to paise with as much as speed as a calculator. 
The substitution of mental calculations by calculators has deprived our young children of exercising their minds. We are doing incalculable harm to our young children by giving them soft options-- no need to learn arithmetic tables, no need to strain the mind to do calculations as the calculators can do the work, no need to read a book as there is a Wikipedia to give the summary, no need to read a newspaper when there are any number of 24x7 news channels, no need to do any home assignment or holiday project when Google is at hand. As young children we had the advantage of elders and grandparents asking us to recite shlokas and Sanskrit verses merely to train the mind to find its own strategy of retaining them in memory. The mind itself was valued as a great computer that can store a vast amount of data and knowledge that could be retrieved anytime in a trice. We did our homework without resorting to cut and paste methods and we benefited by it as it reinforced in us the lessons that were taught in the class. The sharpness and focus that we see in the older people is due to the software they had installed in their early years. But the educational administrators and policy makers today are under a mistaken notion that children should not be subjected to mental work forgetting that only the young minds,  ‘unfettered by the fretful fever and stir of the world’(Wordsworth) are fresh, fertile and capable of quick and easy absorption. Children are the best learners and they acquire arithmetic skills, language skills and core values with amazing ease.
Our modem education system ignores the earlier concept of ‘ brahmacharya’ (this is not to be limited to boys but extended to girls also) which is based on the fact that the early span of 20-25 years is the period when the mind is at its best to learn, concentrate, absorb, retain, analyze and rationalize knowledge. This is the time to focus on learning and store knowledge and information for the years to follow. But today these early years are wasted on a mistaken perception that this is the time to enjoy! And what kind of enjoyment- not the enjoyment that comes from learning or mastering complex subjects or sharpening one’s mental skills but by aimless drifting and seeking softer options that gratifies the superficial sensual life. Young people idle away their time working on social networks like Facebook and Twitter, listening to music on the i-phone and i-pad and talking on their cellphone  that give them an illusion of being alive and in touch with a host of friends. T.S.Eliot’s lines on Television “Television is a medium of entertainment which permits millions of people to listen to the same joke at the same time, and yet remain lonesome” is true of digital communication of our times. The young boys and girls are good with gadgets and expect more fun from technology and less from human company. They hardly indulge in outdoor activities and delude themselves that they are mentally alive sitting before the computer. The clear signs of physical and mental atrophy among a large section of our youth cannot be wished away. In a recent book,  Alone Together, Sherry Turkle writes: “Technology is seductive when what it offers meets our human vulnerabilities. And as it turns out, we are very vulnerable indeed. We are lonely but fearful of intimacy. Digital connections and the social robot may offer the illusion of companionship without the demands of friendship. Our network life allows us to hide from each other, even as we are tethered to each other…we would rather text than talk.”  
It is imperative for us, teachers, to pull the young out of the deep morass into which they have fallen. If we want to preserve the priceless asset that we have in our youth (which is the despair of the West today), we have to instill in them the need, the urgency and the compulsion to be disciplined and have focused learning in order to acquire robust mental skills to meet the challenges of life as they move into the next phase of life. We have to bring back to them the wonder of the printed page. The experience of holding a novel in hand and reading is a liberating exercise. It enables the young to be liberated from the usual way of looking at the world and thinking about themselves and about the world they live in. The world created by the author is through his/her leap of imagination and helps the readers to create that world in their imagination and share a glimpse of that hidden world. Teachers have to be creative and imaginative to reveal the splendour of that hidden world in books. This is the world that the young can share with the writer and with their fellow readers. Unfortunately the teachers have also found shortcuts to reading and are no longer in a position to inspire the young.  Appreciation of great works of art and literature stimulates the power within the readers and helps to apprehend the transfer of power from the author to them.
Our modern youth has to be taught that there is a time for fun, there is a time for study, there is a time for Facebook, there is a time for reading books, there is a time for twittering, there is a time for enquiry there is a time for passive absorption, there is a time for active involvement, there is a time for companionship and  there is a time for contemplation. Teachers have to provide the necessary impetus for the young students to appreciate and value time so that the young enjoy learning alongside having fun. This was the education the older generation had at a time when there was no technology. Educationists may have to remind themselves that the inheritance they had received from their elders should now be passed on to their younger generation whose soft options are but an inhibiting luxury. 


Wednesday, 18 July 2012

Walk the Wisdom



                                     Walk the Wisdom
I have made a habit of going on morning walks for want of anything better to do in my age of retirement. The newspapers are no longer a  ‘must-read’ in the mornings; on the contrary, they are alarming with screechy headlines  about some scam or rape or murder or accident  or about the seasonal flu varying from dengue to chikungunya,  from bird flu to swine flu that occur  with clock-like precision with the change of weather. Sitting cross-legged on the sofa, sipping a cup of coffee and glancing through newspapers is no longer a pleasurable morning pastime. In the post-retirement age, when there is no timeline to meet, we seek new activities to expend all the available time and energy. Like many other septuagenarians, I have chosen morning walks that guarantee longevity and act as a magical panacea against blood pressure, stroke, arthritis, Alzheimer, cardiac arrest-name any disease associated with old age.
These walks have given me new lessons that I had never learnt all these years.  I live in a government built colony which also claims to be a gated colony (only because all gates are closed for the most part of the day) but without any of the shared amenities that enjoy social prestige in privately built multi-storeyed buildings. My walks are limited to walking within the colony till it is time for breakfast. The early hours before the cars and school vans zoom in and out of the colony to pick up children are quiet except for the sound of the broomsticks clearing away the previous day’s deposit of coco-cola cans, beer bottles, wafer cartons, paper plates with leftovers, ice cream cups not to leave out the mainstay of roads- dust and dogs’ excretion, filth and fallen leaves.  I meet the road sweepers everyday- the older men and women greet me with ‘Ram, ram’ and stop heaving their long brooms lest the dust should blow in to my face.  They still live in the old world culture that accepts social hierarchy as ‘given’. They have made an art of wielding the broom and do not stop till the last speck of dust is blown away into pits and dustbins. They are loud, talkative and noisy as they sit under a tree and drink from tiny plastic cups, hot tea brought in a polythene bag from the tea vendor outside the gate. They engage in loud and cynical talks often about the haughty and eccentric behavior of the colony residents.  While they indulge in memsahib bashing, their sons and daughters arrive in a moped or a bike to start their work. They are better off than their seniors who travel in crowded buses, nevertheless they look sullen, cheerless and glum and look disapprovingly at the tea party of the older group. They hardly exchange words with them and keep listening to music on their cell phone, swaying their broom more likely to the Bollywood beats. They wear blue jeans and ill fitting sneakers bought from the pavement vendors to show that they do not belong to the kurta- pyjama,  salwar-kameez era. As I walk past them, they stare at me with anger and hatred and heave their brooms with a vengeance to blow the dust all over me. Their demeanour and conduct seem to mock at my leisurely enjoyment of doing nothing and walking around while they have to work with broomsticks to keep the streets clean for me and my likes.  They had never been to school nor had any skill training. The only skill they have acquired is from their parents to wield the broom.  Their resentment and anger is understandable since they had been denied the option to choose pen and pencil over broomsticks. 
But they have their own dreams for their children. They wish to see them educated and employed in white-collared jobs. The Bollywood films and the TV serials and reality shows have given them hope that their children may also attain higher lifestyle through education, singing and dancing. One can see the desperation in their eyes to  yearn for a better life - if not for themselves, at least for their children. But reality is far from dream. They know and fear that it will be déjà vu all over again.   “Even the loveliest dream bears like a blemish, its difference from reality/ the awareness that what it grants is mere illusion”.  These words of Adorno sum up their despair.
The generation gap is nowhere more evident than amongst the senior and junior road sweepers. While I acknowledge the greetings of the older men and women, I experience no anger or resentment against the younger ones who do not greet me nor care if dust is blown into my eyes. At 70, I empathize with their desires that are overridden by disappointment- something I would not have felt twenty years back. I am happy that  the RTE Act passed by the Parliament  holds out hope for them, making education a fundamental right of every child and mandating all private schools to reserve 25% of seats to children from poor families (to be reimbursed by the state as part of the public-private partnership plan). But my own sons and daughters resent the idea of such lop-sided inclusiveness in schools. They do not share my excitement over RTE as they fear it would impede their children from acquiring intellectual growth and social graces. I notice the generation gap manifest in the absence and presence respectively of fiery competitive spirit between me at 70+ and they at 40+.
All through my teaching years that spanned four and a half decades in colleges and universities, I had been an avid advocate of quality at the expense of quantity in education. I always had my eyes set in the skies desirous of making Indian universities world class universities. I knew that this was possible only with reduced number of intake at the graduate and post-graduate levels. I had spoken and written against democratization of education that conflicted with meritocracy. But the daily silent walks in the mornings opened my eyes to see the burning desire among the less privileged to make their wards progress in life through education that had been denied to them when they were young. They want their children to get better skills other than wielding a broom stick. They live in dreams and they know that dreams are true while they last, but waking up is to agonizingly experience reality bites. It is this that provokes their anger and resentment at seeing people like me walking as a pleasurable exercise and at my children, driving to gyms while they sweep the roads and let their children play in the mud. When I return from my walk I see my grandson getting into the school bus while the sweeper’s son stands and stares with awe and despair if he would be any day a privileged child in the distant future. For him and his parents, hope is the only buffer against desperation. The Bible says “Hope deferred maketh the heart sick; when it blooms it is the tree of life”. All human wisdom is contained in these two words, 'Wait and Hope.”

There is a proverb in Tamil that says what does not grow in five years cannot grow in fifty years. I now know for certain the reverse-what one does not learn at 17 may well be learnt at 70.

Friday, 15 June 2012

Goat, Tiger and Grass stack


                                                                        Goat, Tiger and Grass stack
          I am reminded of a puzzle my father gave me to solve when I was in the third standard. This was about the goat, tiger and the grass stack to be ferried across the river in a basket boat that had space only for two occupants. Since the boatman had to be a constant fixture, he had to make three trips to ferry all three to the other shore. The problem was he could not leave the tiger with the goat or the goat with the grass on either shore .If he took the goat leaving the tiger and the grass, on his next trip, he faced the choiceless choice of leaving either the grass stack with the goat or the tiger with the goat which would provide a sumptuous repast for one of the two- the goat or the tiger. The puzzle remained unsolved till my father told me that the key to the solution was the space for two in the boat. I leave the puzzle at this point to you to solve the boatman’s predicament. This puzzle sums up the political puzzle of electing our next President where the space is limited to one alone. We have a Bengali versus another Bengali (Pranab vs Somnath), a Muslim technocrat versus a Muslim diplomat (Kalam vs Ansari), a SC versus a ST (Meira Kumar vs Sangma) or PM (Manmohan Singh) versus PM(Pranab Mukherjee). It is ludicrous to renominate Abdul Kalam. Even assuming him to be a role model, in this country with a billion people can’t there be two Kalams but only one? M&M have muddied the waters for the BJP and AIADMK to fish  in troubled waters while Congress continues testing the waters in an effort to reach a consensus. The puzzle remains unsolved unless the boat(wo)man comes up with a trump ace.
The Congress has been put in a quandary despite the fact that M&M are in agreement with Madame Sonia that PM should be the 13th President. M&M say that PM shall be the next President while Sonia’s choice is also PM-(Pranab Mukherjee). Our desi M&M, like the American M&M (candies with letter ‘m ’printed on one side) that fills candy shells with a variety of colorful chocolate centres has made the President’s post an empty shell into which they can have their signature fillings. M&M’s personal bitterness, inflated ego and vaulting ambition have left a bitter taste not just for the government in power, but for the whole nation. While politicians take umbrage in the saying that there are no permanent friends or foes in politics, this does not give license to political leaders to don the robes of an Assange and leak out what transpired in a one-to-one meeting with the host who had invited them. Since Sonia had not revealed the names till there was a consensus, it is downright chicanery on the part of the Bengal M to make the names public. As for the other M, he thinks it morally right to run with the hare and hunt with the hound. Seated next to Sonia on the anniversary bash of UPAII, he led her along the garden path assuring her of his support. Congress was lulled into complacency without noticing his newfound bonhomie with his counterpart M.  The two M’s have displayed crass Machiavellianism, in their employment of cunning and duplicity in statecraft and in general conduct. It would have been in order to list out their preferences to the UPA chief as they are still its allies.  They have a right to make their choice public but they have no right to make Sonia’s choice public. It is an act of betrayal- something we Indians have to be wary of as we had allowed the Mughal and the Britsh conquest through the internecine betrayal and rivalry of the Hindu rulers. The BJP has had a martyred grievance that it had not been approached by the arrogant Congress, forgetting that even before the race to Raisina Hill began, Madame Swaraj decisively ruled out support to any Congress nominee-especially Pranab as a Congressman and Ansari as a man of no substance. Its frequent assertions that we will keep our cards close to our chest and will play a wait and watch game show scant respect for the high office of the President. Congress may now feel back stabbed by M&M, but it has no one to blame except itself. Unlike other times as in the Lokpal Bill, FDI in Retail, NCTC, FDI in Pension, this time it had been assiduously working to take the allies with it, but it failed to see M&M”s writing on the wall.
While our political pundits discuss the fallout of M&M’s googly, what is most distressing is that the highest office of the president has been cheapened through murky intrigues and unscrupulous wheeler dealers. It is unfortunate that in the last few weeks’ debate about the next President, no one talked about what qualities are required to be the President of India, but only in terms of minority, caste, religion, gender and de facto domicile(from North or South or East or West  or North-East of India.). It is sad that we cannot expect our politicians to leave aside their personal and party prejudices to look for a President who has faith in our people, in our Parliament, empathy and compassion, honesty and integrity, courage of conviction founded upon social and moral responsibility.  The political drama or tamasha has shown that our politicians are not looking for a person of erudition and wisdom who will bring back a humane, ethical and moral society.
 Indian Republic today needs an active President who will lead the bickering politicians to replace their present trend of packaging humanity into politics by packaging politics into humanity. Can we expect our politicians to give up their egoism, vaulting ambition and mindless intrigues and showcase to the world that parliamentary democracy in India is strong and vibrant. Democracy that is principled on unity amongst diversity can be best illustrated through the Presidential election in the coming weeks. Let us hope that our political class displays maturity and not play musical chairs to grab the sole seat nor play a game of chess to capture power nor resort to gamesmanship for the sole purpose of defeating the opponents, but play fair and square true to the highest principles of democracy

.  

Wednesday, 6 June 2012

Reflection on XIIth Board Examination Results


                                                        Reflections on  XIIth Board Examination Results
The eagerly awaited XIIth results are out. The results are no different from the previous years- as usual girls have done better, Chennai once again has put up the best performance with a pass percentage of 90.59, (though last year, the pass percentage of Chennai was 91.32), pass results in government schools have improved and high scoring marks all over India  have scaled new heights. The mad scramble for admissions to colleges has begun and the eligibility cut-off for the elite colleges as in the previous years will be 96-99%. Anxiety is writ large on all those young faces whose marks range between 90 and 95, having failed to reach the toppers’ scores by a margin of 3-4 %. With limited number of seats available, their dreams of joining the elite colleges shall remain only dreams. As for the under 90s, the prospects of joining second rung colleges that are next in order of merit are bright. The disappointment for that large number of students who have managed between 70 and 80% is too grim to be written about.  But for the rest who have cleared the XIIth Boards with less percentage, there are umpteen colleges –that are colleges only in name-who have a lower eligibility bar, besides open learning institutions that have a gargantuan space for any number of entrants in search of a degree. In the University of Delhi, the number of seats available in colleges is 54,000 while its Open School of Learning is open to more than a lakh of students. There is also the Indira Gandhi National Open University and a few recognized Distance learning Centres to admit all those who are left behind mainstream college education. In this respect higher education in India attempts to satisfy at least quantitatively, if not qualitatively. The same tilt in favour of quantity over quality is evidenced in the school Board examinations.
The high scores in the Board examinations raise two pertinent issues that pose a challenge to college admission.  They relate to examination and evaluation.  The number of students who took the XIIth Boards – both as regular and private students- is about 81,000 and pass percentage is 80.9%. In terms of arithmetic calculations, a little more than 64,000 students have cleared the examinations this year. Since CBSE caters to all regions within India and a few Indian schools abroad- especially in the Middle East, it is a creditable achievement. But such a result is possible only because the papers are set in such a way that even the below average student can manage to pass. Most of the questions are for two marks barring a couple that are marked out of five. No wonder, the pass percentage is high and higher is the number of students scoring over 90%.
The truth is-with no disparagement intended about the merit of the high scoring percenters- the Board examinations do not test the real intelligence or high order thinking of the students. It is obvious the Boards are more mindful of the below average students passing the examinations than testing students’ knowledge, understanding and their analytical and logical skills. This is not intended to haul the CBSE over the coal as one of the main objectives of CBSE is to focus on the lowest common denominator of the large number of students who can answer simple questions. When the students after school join college, where they have to write long essays and assignments, even the 90 percenters find it difficult to score more than a modest 60-70% or even less than that. As for the others, their attempt at university examinations is pathetic. Thus the disconnect between school learning and college education has disastrous consequences for a majority of students entering the university portals.
The second issue relates to evaluation which varies from region to region. For the last so many years, Tamilnadu has topped the Boards.  What makes Chennai schools different from the rest of the country? Is it that Tamilnadu students are brighter than the rest or are the Chennai teachers far superior to the rest in the country? It is not that one doubts the credentials of Chennai schools, teachers and students, but no one including CBSE has analyzed the reasons behind the spectacular performance of Chennai year after year. If Chennai schools have distinct quality pedagogy, why can’t that be replicated in other schools?  Or is this high scoring and high pass percentage phenomena anything to do with evaluation? Are the Chennai teachers more liberal in marking than teachers elsewhere? Has the CBSE tried to find out what distinguishes Tamilnadu schools? Has it ever taken out the answer sheets of students at random from different regions and compared the evaluation?  
Quantity versus quality is an issue that dogs all educational reforms in the country. With RTE in place, it is imperative to see that no student is denied schooling and denied the opportunity to realize and utilize his capabilities to lead the life that he or she values. Hence the present CBSE system of examination and evaluation will help our young men and women to be educated and use their learning to realize their potential to be gainfully employed. But this does not ensure quality learning. It is time for reflection and action.
CBSE should have two sets of question papers for the XIIth Boards similar to the ‘O’ and  ‘A’ levels in UK. The difference is, unlike UK where the O levels are at the end of the Xth, here both the options should be available only in the XIIth class. The present set of question papers as they are, should be continued as it guarantees a minimum qualification for employment while another set of advanced papers with essay type questions should be offered to those who wish to pursue higher studies in the Universities. The latter must satisfy the minimum entrance qualification required by the universities. Those who wish to pursue university education will have to opt for the advanced level while all others seeking to pursue vocational degree courses can opt for the former. This is one way to make school education integrative both of quality and quantity. This should not be mistaken for discrimination of students as they are given the freedom to opt for any one of them. Accordingly they shall be taught and trained to take up the examinations of their choice. 
It is best to recall Amartya Sen’s theory of  Capability Egalitarianism where the capability approach advocates that the evaluative space should be that of capabilities. Democratization of education should not be limited to making education available to all, but to be expanded to include the right of every individual to raise his bar and to be given the opportunity to realize his attainable outcome. One of the weaknesses of democracy is that in the context of equality and equity it does not have room for merit. All efforts in our country is geared towards LCD(Lowest Common Denominator) which in itself is a good thing, but fails to provide space for HCF (Highest Common Factor)- also called Greatest Common Measure(GCM) or Greatest Common Divisor(GCD). The focus cannot always be only at the lower rungs at the cost of merit and quality. This is particularly true of democracy in education. It is an opportune moment for educationists to institute reforms at the school level to synergize quality and quantity, to ensure reconciliation at the University level of these two imponderables of equity and merit. The Delors report on Education presented to UNESCO in 1994-95 and the Annual Report of the World Bank have expressed the four pillars of learning and development for the 21st Century as learning to be, learning to know, learning to do and learning to live together which is basically the aim  of education- to develop  skilled and educated individuals and set up  Knowledge and Research Institutions, laboratories and Networks that will work with other networks involving  trade, companies, research centres and  manufacturers.
 Can Indian academics with their wisdom and vast experience alter the dynamics of education to bring about a new ideology of learning in our society! I wish we can Obama-like say “Yes, We can”


Saturday, 2 June 2012

Consumer Activism:A Platform for our Rights and Duties


                        
               Consumer Activism: a platform for our rights and duties.
Activism is the doctrine or practice of vigorous action or involvement as a means of achieving political or social goals. There are many types of activism such as the judicial activism, student activism, media activism, internet activism etc, but the most potent, wide-reaching and the most sought after activism is Consumer activism. This is because it is not limited to any specific group like the judiciary or students or the Media, but extends to connect with everyone in the society. It presupposes awareness of unfair practices that affect the consumers and it anticipates redressal of complaints against unsatisfactory products, unfair price and above all it is a potent tool to assert consumer’s rights. Consumer activism helps the consumers to make informed buying decisions- to make buying pro-active. In short, it empowers the Consumer as King, in the sense that he is the final decider and arbiter in any unfair transaction between the seller and the buyer. But the most important element that underlies consumer activism is that it involves some degree of personal sacrifice, a willingness to deny oneself a necessary product or thing in order to demand better quality and fairer price for it. It is this element that is missing in Consumer activism in India. Let me illustrate this from what we experience daily as we shop for fruits and vegetables.
This is the season for mangoes, leechis, melons, tomatoes etc- fruits and vegetables that have a fair amount of water to quench our summer thirst. Invariably every year these are either in short supply or of poor quality ( the better quality fruits are exported to fetch very high price and that too in foreign currency ) or priced beyond the affordability of  consumers who do not belong to that microscopically small percent of the affluent class. The large majority of consumers from the middle and lower middle class have either to buy inferior fruits and vegetables at a high price or pay phenomenal price to buy quality products.  It is easy to blame the government for price rise specially relating to the food index, but the real culprit is we, the consumers who surrender to the greed of the sellers. If consumers are ready to forego tomatoes and onions, mangoes and bananas, these perishable items under the scorching sun will soon rot and move out of the store shelves into the garbage dins. Active Consumer movement should unite us all  as consumers to boycott perishable food items that meet neither our purse nor our palate.   Consumer activism can succeed if there is a voluntary effort to give up these vegetables and fruits until the prices are brought down as per the Law of demand and supply.  The goal should be to pressurize the sellers to make available fruits and vegetables of better quality at affordable price.  It is this united movement that is missing in our society. It is a sad reflection of our mindset that prioritizes selfishness to obtain for oneself goods and products without a thought for the millions who have to do without them. The development of social awareness with regard to consumer activism is closely linked to the development of moral and spiritual awareness. Embedded in this movement are morality, selflessness, sacrifice and united effort to make the traders and sellers recognize the power of Consumer activism.
The operation of consumer activism is needed in cases of adulteration- adulteration of edible oils, water, milk, foodstuff like rice, flour and pulses, medicines, besides fuel that corrode the car engine and cause  kitchen fire. There is certainly legal recourse to all these adulterated products and unfair practices, but in our country the judicial wheel moves slowly and never reaches its destination. Unlike the USA where consumer movements have developed as a potent form of resistance against unethical marketing and industrial practices, in India, the movement often gets stymied for lack of united effort. Traders know that they can sell goods of whatever quality as there is no strong protest movement that unites all consumers. Organizations like consumer forum, Shoutout etc have boldly emerged to take the traders bull by their horns. But these organizations need grassroots level support through boycott of goods that are quality-wise low and price-wise high.
Consumer is King-  because of his commitment to the cause of his fellow beings, because of his awareness of the unethical practices among the traders and shopkeepers, because of his courage to renounce all those products until their quality and fair price are ensured.  This is yet another fight against corruption- corruption that is insidious and working in a hidden injurious way. Let the Consumers of India unite to overcome all injustices, immoral practices and deceit in their transaction with traders and shopkeepers.
Consumer activism is not limited to ethical shopping, ethical purchase behavior, ethical consumption only, but it also includes action against ethical wastage so that less privileged consumers can have access to them. In many families, medicines that include vitamins and anti-biotics and tonics lie unused. Consumer organizations should keep cardboard boxes in prominent places in different neighbourhoods where consumers can deposit the unused medicines. If these medicines are within expiry date, these activist organizations can deposit them in hospital and charity clinics. We travel on roads, walk on streets and move around markets. Thus we are consumers of the state’s largesse to us. While it is our right to protest if roads are bad, streets are filthy and markets are disgustingly dirty, we also have our share in maintaining them. Consumer activism extends beyond rights to acceptance of responsibility. As consumers, we should not make our roads garbage dins, nor waste power and water so that others can share the available limited necessities with the rest of us.
Consumer Activism starts with consumers’ duty before it becomes consumer’s rights.