Wednesday, 2 January 2013

The Three Wise Monkeys


                                                            The Three Wise Monkeys
The Three Wise Monkeys, sometimes known as the three Mystic Apes embody the proverbial maxim-‘See no evil, hear no evil and speak no evil’. The Congress steered by Sonia Gandhi and her backseat driver,  Rahul Gandhi feels impelled to live up to the hallowed surname Gandhi by following the Mahatma’s ideal of the three wise monkeys. Hence there is not a squeak from the Congress government, from the two Gandhis and from their PM appointee, Manmohan Singh or for that matter any of his cabinet ministers and colleagues on any issue the nation is agitated about. It is left to the Congress spokespersons to cobble up arguments in defence of their silence that signifies nothing.
The government’s silence is often mistaken for apathy whereas it is nothing but sheer ignorance of the power of the social media in the hands of the aspirational youth and the consequent incompetence to meet it. The antediluvian mind set of our political class has failed to recognize that the power of the people is today stronger than the people in power.  It has failed to understand the digital connectivity that brings people together to protest against what they perceive as a denial of justice and denial of their citizenship right to honest and good governance.  The unprecedented growth of new forms of insta -communication has given rise to new forms of solidarity that is not driven by any exceptional leader or by any ideology.   
It started with Anna Hazares anti-corruption movement last year, when the Government failed to read the pent up frustration of the ordinary Indian against bureaucratic corruption that forced him to bribe his way to lead a life of modest standards. The late response by the government was like closing the stable door after the horse had bolted. The government buckled under pressure and the PM’s reverential plea to Anna Hazare to break his fast with a promise to get the parliament enact the Lokpal Bill was seen as a victory for the Delhi spring.  The government’s subsequent clumsy handling of Ramdev’s arrest only catapulted him to the national stage till then occupied by Anna Hazare. The government has now scored a hat -trick with its inept handling of the youth protests in the wake of the most heinous and dastardly crime against a young woman in the capital. Even though the government cannot be held responsible for the savagery and brutality of the gang rape it underestimated the anger and despair of India’s youth who called for a strong and swift response from the government. Congress failed to gauge the angry cry of the youth demanding more security and safety for women while mourning the death of the brave young woman who had shown exemplary courage and determination to bring the assaulters to justice. This youth movement did not have anyone like Anna Hazare or Ramdev to give it direction; it was spontaneous and fuelled by twitter messages. Amidst all this chaos, for a week the cow and the calf duo kept an enigmatic silence as though it was government’s inept handling that had nothing to do with their leadership. The late night meeting of Mrs. Gandhi with some protestors after a week was like offering a rattle to a crying baby. 
But it is naive to nail the Gandhis as feelingless as both mother and son had experienced terrible tragedies in their lives. One should remember that the wisdom arising out of tragedy is that it offers no comfort or rational understanding to its victims.  The Gandhis are no exceptions. They have endured terrible tragedies  with stoicism and thereafter seem to have become immune to the voices that raise against unjust and irrational killings..

The challenge today is very different from that of 2009 when the Congress under UPA coalition was voted back to power-and that too in the shadow of 26/11 tragedy. In the last few years,a new generation of young voters who have been aptly described as “consumers of democracy’ has risen up demanding efficiency in governance and speedy results. These young men and women who are gathered in Jantar Mantar for the last fortnight are impatient and they have demonstrated that they have a voice to drown the silence of the rulers.

The nation needs rulers who function like dynamic CEOs and run the government. There is
certainly no lack of educated, efficient and honest people in our midst. We do not need ageing, pontificating political leaders who are often aggressive, assertive and belligerent, wearing their morals on their sleeves. Congress can boast of educated and brilliant ministers among the younger lot that includes Ashwini Kumar, Shashi Tharoor, Jairam Ramesh, Jyotiraditya Scindia, Sachin Pilot, Milind Deoras, R.K.Singh, Naveen Jindal, Manish Tiwari  etcin addition to older ministers like Chidambaram, Khurshid,Kapil Sibal and the like. They are suave, polite and can relate to the youth of the country. It is time for the Congress to turn to its young brigade to speak up. The dynastic compulsion has kept these young people under leash and though they are well educated and articulate they are neither visible nor are they heard. The Congress party seems to close its eyes, shut its ears and tie its tongue like the three  ‘wise’ monkeys.

Irresponsible political parties are queering the pitch for a revolution on the lines of the Arab spring which had to a large extent failed in Egypt. Let us not enter a world of anarchy as the middle class revolution has no specific ideology except that it demands good and honest governance. It has today demonstrated its power giving vent to unfiltered emotions of anger and despair but fortunately for India, it has not till now let loose anarchy. The youth is justifiably angry, desperate and impatient. Their distraught feelings are raw but they can be channelized. If not, this will lead to lawlessness and disorder in our society. Lumpen elements will take advantage of the lawful and directionless anger of the youth and let loose violence and riot. In today’s spontaneous protests and candle lighting, it would have been great if the young men had also taken a pledge either in Rajghat or in Jantar Mantar that they will respect women, will not seek dowry and will ensure womens’ right to equal status that they enjoy. Protests cannot remain forever empty sloganeering. They have to be followed by commitment to a cause. It is the duty of the State to protect its citizens but it is the duty of the citizens to assist the State in its discharge of duty.  

It is time for the Congress to do soul searching. It is time for the Congress to look to dynamic young leaders who can relate to and communicate with their own generation. The Finance Minister spoke the truth that the government had not been fully prepared to deal with the youth uprising. It is time for the ruling party to blood the younger educated parliamentarians to engage with the youth of this country. This obsession with dynastic rule has to be given up. If Congress prides itself on inner democracy –that Rahul has been striving to enforce- the first step is to discover the leader who can speak to our youth, inspire them, motivate them and convert their spontaneous anger  to something positive. They are desperately looking for inspired leadership to channel their raw and untempered emotions. We do not need passive cows and calves; we need active, strong, intelligent, compassionate and articulate leaders of deep integrity and commitment who understand the change in government-people equation and who knows the art of getting our youth to transform their unfiltered passion into constructive action.  Let us hope Congress throws up a new generation of leaders who can showcase our demographic dividend as the window of opportunity to develop our nation in the coming decades. 

Rahul may be a well meaning individual but he lacks charisma to lead a disillusioned and cynical generation from the educated middle class.  ‘Garibi hatao’ struck a chord with the poor in the ‘70s and ‘80s, but four decades later holding on to the same slogan before a rising generation labelled YOLO generation ( you live only once) is not just being short sighted, but blind to its aspirations and dreams for better and secure living. If many of the younger parliamentarians have given up their khadi dress and Nehruvian cap and are sporting western clothes like the CEOs, their mindset has also to change to go for a development model that guarantees quality education, ample employable opportunities, good healthcare, safe and secure living. This goes beyond the staid slogan of providing sub-standard ‘roti,kapda and makan’.
s
Can India rise once more just as it did after the liberalization of economy in the ‘90s? Can Congress deliver as it did then? Can it wean itself off the apron strings of the Gandhi and venture boldly to meet the aspirations of the youth? Can it convert the demographic dividend to advantage by providing opportunities to the new generation to achieve its capability potential? The answer can be ‘Yes’ if Gandhis themselves gracefully pave the way for the younger leaders to take the reins. A hallowed surname is not enough today; it has to speak and live the ideals  that surname exemplifies. The ideal of the three wise monkeys is to be blind. deaf and mute to evil. The modern version of three wise monkeys is to recognize that the youth of this nation is no evil and hence the need of the hour is to see, hear and speak to them and integrate them  in the task of rebuilding a shattered nation.

Wednesday, 28 November 2012

Apologia Pro Vita Sari


                                                                  Apologia Pro Vita Sari*
*(The title is a take-off from Cardinal Newman’s Apologia pro Vita Sua which when translated reads “Defense of one's life: a written justification for one's beliefs or course of conduct)                                          


The news report about IIM (Ahmedabad) female graduates opting to appear in sari for the placement interviews made interesting read. For the first time, IIM(A) had given the nod for the recognition of sari as a formal wear for business interviews. This is a refreshing change from the unwomanly business suits that our fair sex executives have been sporting for their corporate offices. Just as Newman wrote his great book to justify his beliefs, this piece is intended to justify the worth of sari in today’s world.
 The word sari is a corrupt form of Sati from Sanskrit and Prakrit meaning a strip of cloth. It had an early mention in the Jatakas, the Buddhist Jain literature to describe women’s attire in ancient India. The sari developed as a graceful garment in both South and North India at around the same time, and is now regarded as an epitome of Indian culture. The sari stands as a symbol of grace that adequately covers women while displaying the curves at the right places.
But in the last few decades, more so after the economic liberalization of the 1990s, sari has yielded its place to western attire in the Indian corporate world. In fact, the idea of Indian woman outside home and in a workplace is primarily due to the western influence.  Female education and employment began in the 19th century during the British regime. Post Independence, women’s education and employment have expanded and a section of Indian women--the elite and the upper middle class-- have moved forward considerably. Thanks to the exposure to global network, more women are engaged in business enterprises and have greater career opportunities both in the private and public sectors. More and more women have taken to the western attire citing convenience at the place of work (no one wonders how sari does not hinder work in the kitchen). Today apart from women executives, those engaged in front offices in the corporate sector and those engaged as personal secretaries to corporate honchos have gone for a complete makeover with the poor sari relegated to home wear  by maids and stay home women. It is a sad commentary on the mindset of corporate and business industry as they insist on a dress code modelled on western outfits.
I am not critical of all that is western. In fact Western literature, music and theatre have been my intellectual and emotional companions. But when it comes to dress, I hold sari as a supreme and fascinating invention of human creativity. I am not a conservative prude who wants our women to go behind the gunghat. But I am certainly an aficionado of tasteful dressing that combines aesthetics with feminine grace. The Kiss principle (keep it simple and sophisticated) of design   seems to have ignored the elegance of sari in the workplace as it is applied only to business suits, skirts and blouses.

Shakespeare said :  ‘Apparel oft proclaims the Man’.  It is true of the woman as well.  But modern woman is more tuned to another Shakespearean aphorism that says: ‘Every time a woman leaves off something she looks better, but every time a man leaves off something he looks worse.’ Hence she has chosen to leave off sari that drapes her fully with the possible exception of the midriff that is covered by the elegant blouse making everyone trying to imagine ‘choli ke peechay kya hai’. But the skirts – most of them mini or midi –do not leave anything for imagination and curiosity.  It was Anatole France who said that ‘to imagine is everything, to know is nothing at all’.  And as imagination attempts to capture things unknown, sari gives to women an individuality and a mystery that is unique and distinguished.
The western attire looks best on women who have the perfect figure with the right degree of slimness and height, preferably size zero. But sari is a dress for all size and figures.  It is long enough to cover the subject and short enough to provoke interest. It reveals the curves as much as it conceals them. Unlike the business suits that tend to be stiff and linear, sari with its free fall makes it flexile and curving that enhances feminine grace. It is also a dress for all seasons.  During winter it gives the protective warmth; in summer it protects the skin from the scorching heat.

But more than anything, it stands to reason for women to have their own unique identity by having a dress of their own without shining in borrowed male attire.  Let Indian women return to Sari with its exclusivity, glamour, charm and grace to make a style statement.  With its unique draping style, sari transforms a woman into a diva- ‘feminine, classic and confident’.


Thursday, 18 October 2012

Parliament is dead; long live the Parliament.


                                                 Parliament is dead; long live the Parliament.
I am not a celebrity, nor am I one of the Mango people deprived of the basic comforts essential to lead a decent life.  I am a middle class educated professional with no special claims to be heard or be written about. But what I say below is an echo of many others like me- and in that respect I am one of the Common Man (aam-admi) even if I do not fully subscribe to the order of Mango people.
I am sad- no, that is not correct as that would mean I am beyond consolation.
I am depressed- no, that is also not correct as that would mean I am vanquished beyond hope of recovery
I am angry- no - that is not correct as that would mean some degree of affinity with the person I am angry with and I have no affinity with anyone to be cross with.
No, the truth is I am simply frightened, shattered and paralyzed witnessing our rapid descent towards anarchy. There is nothing to hold us back as we have lost respect for our secular Bible- the Constitution of India. For 65 years the Constitution was a bulwark against anti-democratic forces. Thanks to the Constitution framed by legal luminaries, we did not go  the Chinese way opting for a single party rule nor for the military dictatorship of Pakistan( though even today their parliamentary governance is handmaiden to the Army) nor the Presidential form of democracy of USA, but followed the Westminster form of Parliamentary democracy. We had enjoyed for six decades after independence a reasonably good democracy that was built upon the Constitution to establish the structure, procedures, powers, and duties of government institutions, and to set out fundamental rights, directive principles, and the duties of citizens. Freedom of speech was one of the rights it bestowed on the people of India. For almost six and a half decades, our democracy had been sustained by our veneration of the Constitution as the Supreme Law of India. Parliament, judiciary, Legislative Assembly and all institutions set up by the Act of Parliament held the country together that bestowed individual freedom on its people to vote in and vote out members of Parliament every five years.  We accepted the Acts legislated by the Parliament, we respected the institutions mainly the judiciary, we resolved our differences within the laws framed by the Constitution and we governed ourselves as a democratic nation.
Today all these sacred institutions have become suspect. Corruption has become stubbornly endemic and pervasive among all sections of our society. Nothing gets done without the exchange of pelf. Corruption has become a way of life. Those who do not accept or offer bribes were regarded as aliens from an archaic past. (I recall one of the political members on our college Governing Body( today the lady is top among the  upper echelons of her party)  speaking disparagingly about my refusal to do the party’s bidding in appointments and admissions saying ‘that she will neither eat nor will allow others to eat’. This was stated in her trademark impeccable Hindi.)  
Corruption is not uniquely an Indian phenomenon.  It is in most parts of the world including the developed countries in the West,  but the difference is in the West corruption does not meet with social approval.  Meghnad Desai says, corruption is as Indian as daal-chawal because everyone specially from  the middle class at some point of time has been guilty of giving –if not accepting bribe –to get things done. Henc e it is ironic that these very same people are lending support to the crusade against corruption. The result is corruption has become a potent tool to settle scores with one’s adversaries. This is the most pernicious form of corruption- corruption of the moral fibre of the nation. 
India against corruption started off well under Anna Hazare to pitchfork corruption centrestage. But Anna has found to his dismay that many of those who joined him at Jantar Mantar had many a times compromised on moral principles. The hysterical shout against corruption was a strategic means to deflect attention from their own personal questionable dealings.  When Arvind hijacked Anna ‘s revolution and arrived on stage, Anna withdrew. The ABC of this movement Arvind, Bhushan and Sisodia(where’s’ is pronounced ‘c’ as in’sea’)have launched  a vitriolic attack on parliamentarians as part of a well calculated strategy to show to the world that everyone in India except they and their fledgling group is corrupt. They pronounced from the stage that they have evidence against 15 cabinet ministers and against any number of opposition leaders for their fraudulent dealings involving crores of money. It does not matter if it is 1880 crores (that  Namo, the Incomparable alleged about Mrs.G’s travel –cum-health expenses-though not by ABC) or a smaller sum of 71 lakhs that Salman Khurshid is alleged to have stashed away among equipment for the differently- abled people, the moot point is to make serious allegations so that they tarnish the reputation of all those the trio despises and put the onus on their ‘adversaries’ to prove their innocence. The draft reports surreptitiously accessed by the Media (by bribing the officials concerned) are shown as the final report to malign those named in the report. Having been an Income Tax officer, Arvind knows too well that the draft CAG report is always sent to the party in question for its replies and the final report is then made and signed and sent to the authorities concerned for further action, if needed.  Since the allegations are full of innuendoes and insinuations with or without substantive evidence, it is apparent that the motive  is to cast aspersions and malign his adversaries. ABC does not want to lodge a FIR against the corrupt Ministers and high fliers, for they do not trust the judiciary, do not trust the executive authority, do not trust the Government because everyone is corrupt. Only ABC alone is the truth bearer of this nation. ABC has set a dangerous precedent of making sweeping charges on quarter truths and three fourths lies.  Arvind may be right in his espousal ( time will tell), but such a free for all is fraught with danger as anyone can exercise his freedom of speech and his right to air charges from the street corners. The TV towers have turned towers of Babel where accusation and counter accusations spoken in high decibel drown everything in a  cacophony of  noise.
It has taken many years for our leaders who were in the forefront of the freedom struggle to build our constitution and democratic institutions but it has taken less than three weeks for the ABC to destroy them. The trio wants people’s courts on the streets and the media to conduct trial and pronounce judgements.  Can there be a better and swifter way to let loose anarchy?
ABC has fine tuned the art of fighting on the streets. The  ABC looks at parliament as a house  of thugs( and ironically he wants to get elected to its office) ,courts  full of self seekers, the bureaucracy swarming with dishonest officers ( though  he himself was a bureaucrat), all organizations  suspect and there is no one in this functioning democracy who can be trusted.  ABC wants to shape the nation’s policies by giving voice to the people and expects theirs to be the distilled voice of wisdom.  
Where does this leave Arvind and his fledgling political party? He wants to get elected to parliament which he holds in utter contempt today. Will he lead the country or will he allow people to rule from the streets as he has shown the way.  No institution can function if multiple voices are given the freedom to direct its activities. ABC seems to believe that  espousal of corruption is a magic wand that will solve all the ills of the country. Manna, honey  and milk will flow through the land and everyone will be assured of his/her share and Ram Rajya will  be once again brought back.  Since no constitutional body as it exists today is trust worthy, the people’s darbar will deliberate on all issues- home, defence, finance, food, foreign policies etc and govern the nation from the streets. The army will march not to the command of a general but to the direction of every Jawan who is a  part of the aam-admi. The Ministries will function to the policies enacted on the streets. Schools, colleges and universities will function according to what every individual  desires for his/her ward .We will showcase to the world a vibrant democracy that functions from its streets. I do not know what role ABC will play .Will they preside over the people in which case what happens to people’s power?  Will they seek their vote in which case they have to once again bring back all the constitutional bodies that had been vilified by them now.
 ABC believes in fomenting anarchy for utopia to follow. But the frightening question is can the country be rescued once anarchy sets in?
I am frightened to see Parliament brought to the streets. I am frightened for whom will ABC toll today, tomorrow, day after and day day after. I hope and pray ‘that it does not toll  for me’ for my blasphemous writing.
I am frightened to hear ABC’s obituaries on Parliament. Yes, I am frightened because no one dares to  say  “Parliament is dead ;  Long live our Parliament.”

Sunday, 14 October 2012

An Ode to Kejrewall by Fellow Politicians


                                          An Ode to Kejrewall by Fellow Politicians
(with apologies to Gulzar's translation of  'Kajrare,Kajrare' from Bunty aur Babli


Kejrewall, Kejrewal'
Welcome to our muchmaigned tribe
 With such a vicious tongue do you paint us all, as scums of the earth, ,
That we politicians feel a knife through our reputation


                     We have lost our name, fame and status; now take your eyes off us,
O merciless slanderer!
After all, it's people of your own tribe you're destroying.
                                                            With your half lies and quarter truths

Kejrewall,Kejrewall
                                                             Your  kaale-kaale exposes about us
                                                             Are  kajra re naina for
                                                            u know and we know they are kale-kaale
                                                           black nothings, (kajra re nai-na)

                   Your allegations, innuendoes and insinuations spoken with venom,
                                                       speak our own language
                                    Your barbs leave a mark on the helpless mango people
                                                      When you speak you spit venom but  
                                                      betray the goal you seek after
                                                         



Your words have the fragrance of kimam, spiced and flavoured with hot masala
                                 You say, like we do that your heart
                                  bleeds for your countrymen
                                You are like anyone of us grinding our noses in muck
                                You are smarter than us as you put on the Gandhi cap
                                though  un- Gandhian like ,
                              Your words all times cross the limits and you destroy all decency.
But even while doing so, you cleverly keep your eyelids downcast,
                                 because you wish to see only the dirt

                               Slander us, slander us
We are so used to slandering others that it does not hurt when the slanderer
                                is also one of  our own tribe


We still remember meeting you in Jantar Mantar. The entire city greeted you
                    with  ‘I am Anna Cap’ as symbol of their love.
                    From Jantar Mantar to Ram Lila grounds to Ambedkar stadium, your rise is
                    Higher than Goliath.
                   There are no Davids in the horizon to fight you
                   In the name of IAC, you have taken away Anna’s crusade
                   To save Anna from fast unto death
                                     
                                                  Kejrewall, Kejrewall
                                    Politician, thy name is Kejrewall, Kejrewall