Monday, 21 April 2014

Indian Nob(e)lity




                                                               Indian Nob(e)lity
Almost all Sunday newspapers carried the proud news of a Kolkatta teen Arunavha Chanda receiving admission offers from seven American Universities- mostly IVY league after acing a perfect score in SAT. An exceptionally bright student, he has been a topper from class II to class XII. With all the  newspapers currently poll vaulting to abysmal depths through publishing  sensational news about acrimonious, boorish and coarse  exchange of words between different political leaders, this success story of Arunavha’s tryst with excellence was really a shot in the arm for the sagging  Indian morale. I was delighted to read about the achievement of the nineteen year old youngster – a delight I shared with millions of Indians who would have accessed this news from the newspapers.
Somewhere along with that delight came a thought of grief as I muttered inaudibly that Ameica’s gain is India’s loss. India’s generosity is legendary and here is one more instance of her gifting to US another Hargobind Khorana, another SubrahmanyanChandrasekhar, another Venkatraman Ramakrishnan to add to the glorious American list of Indian born American desi Nobel Laureates. There has been no Indian born Indian desi after C.V.Raman to get the coveted Nobel prize for Science. The only one who comes closest to him is Pachauri who was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 2007 on behalf of the Intergovernmental Panel of scientists on Climate Change (IPCC) that he headed, an award he shared with the then American Vice President Al Gore.
In the past, young bright Indians used to take wings after their first degree in Engineering or Medicine and very rarely in Arts and Commerce, but today they all fly just after finishing school. Ten years back as a university teacher, I used to write testimonials for my students who wished to go abroad (with or without financial assistance) and encourage them to experience the Western world of academics with its stress on self learning in contrast to the spoon feeding that we do in our colleges and universities. I wanted them to have an exposure to a different culture and a different way of living that allowed the younger generation to cultivate freedom of the mind, freedom of expression and freedom of action. I wanted them to appreciate and value hard work that is inhered in the concept ‘Earn as you Learn’ and pay their way to university studies. I wanted them to understand the spirit of independence that western education instilled in the youngsters. I was then in my early 30s and therefore I cherished  naïve hopes of these young men and women returning home academically, professionally and personally well trained and educated to serve their motherland as scientists, engineers, doctors and administrators. Those hopes never fructified as none of these bright students came back home. Today the student exodus is not limited to the brightest bunch; the foreign bug has infected even ordinary students because they have no hope of securing admission in the hallowed portals of IITs and IIMs, Medical Colleges and Law Institutes. It is much easy to get bank loans (with parents standing surety and taking responsibility) and go abroad for a MBA or MS and then get slowly absorbed (after a considerable wait) as US citizens. This is because back home it is a battle first to get admission  in colleges, and still worse later to get decent employment after completing the studies. A Commerce student finds it difficult to get into MBA or complete CA (Chartered Accountancy) and prefers the easier route of going abroad even to a second grade university to get the three letters tagged to his name. The few  years of study in US toughens him and he easily saunters into US society ready to do any job that he would have abhorred back home. After all a  dollar is a dollar worth 60 rupees (at today’s rate of exchange) and the freedom to spend it gives him greater joy than a return to a life loaded with responsibility, where to live as you like is either a luxury or deemed preposterous.
As for the talented bright minds, America is the acme of academic excellence. The harsh truth is even the best of Indian universities (that include IITs and IIMs) cannot hold a candle before a Harvard or a Yale or anyone of the IVY League universities in US. It is unfortunate that Indian universities do not have the academic ambience that some of the top world universities have. We have mistakenly equated academic excellence with elitism, a term that is incongruent with the idea of democracy. We are warped in an archaic mindset that refuses to allow the blossoming of merit since it interferes with the democratic right of equity, equality and impartiality.  It is essential that everyone gets the right to education but that should not conflict with the right of the intellectually gifted to special endowments that are needed to pursue quality research and scholarly investigation.  Superior gifts merit superior education, position and esteem even if it conflicts with the egalitarian principles of democracy. One has to recall John Rawls endorsement of elitism- specially intellectual and academic elitism- as it ‘permits people to possess and cultivate superior talents… to benefit the most disadvantaged part of society.’ America provides the right atmosphere to pursue research of high quality that could be transferred to the progress of mankind. No wonder, the best of brains from all over the world are drawn to US and the US, in turn welcomes them with open arms and drafts them into its academic community as elitist American citizens.
Arunavha will be the new member to become a part of this exclusivity – a tempting and well meaning offer to young man from a society that mistakenly prides itself of being non--exclusionist and non-elitist. This is at its worst nothing but egalitarian charlatanism, what Allan Bloom terms as ‘as egalitarian Tartufferie’ (from Moliere’s comedy Tartuffe or the Impostor).
 I am happy for Arunavha and wish him the very best of opportunities to realize his academic and intellectual potential. I wish he returns home at some point of time to make his rich learning and research available to the Indian universities that need to be lifted out of their current singular approach towards practical equality to an inclusive approach to accommodate the right of meritocracy that provides intellectual exhilaration to university education. The return of Arunavhas will signal the end of the famed Indian nob(e)lity and provide   a glimmer of hope for the renaissance of Indian University education whose horizon has become too  narrow and dark to resemble a cave. This article has been necessitated to serve as a timely utterance to give relief to my thought of grief that set in after the initial euphoric joy of hearing Arunahva’s success.



Thursday, 17 April 2014

Why do I write




                                                                           Why Do I Write
I had been writing almost non-stop for the last eight years in my post retirement period. While I was in service, in keeping with the requirements of my academic profession my writings were limited to books, essays and lectures on literature.  The productive post retirement phase has given  me plenty of time to read and write  books on subjects other than literature such as Higher Education,  Inter-Religious Harmony and even my life story. The last mentioned is an attempt to live through my long years -75 to be precise and it is not to be mistaken as the memoirs of a celebrity meant to be inspirational and motivational. It is simply a recount of a life lived long in time and short in succulence. Not a day passes without my fingers thumping on the laptop since I have developed a new interest in blogging. My blogs span politics, current affairs and personal observations on life around us.  
But after eight years, a kind of weariness has come over me. The title of this piece expresses the constant echo within me as to why I write. In fact no one reads these days and among those who read, majority prefers pulp fiction or sensational exposure of celebrities in glossy magazines but not any serious stuff. When I sent complimentary copies of my book on Higher Education to my friends and close relatives, apart from the usual response –‘Great’, ‘Well done’ or ‘Indeed a much needed book for our times’ etc,   everyone including academics and Vice- Chancellors (for whom, I thought the book will be of great value) did not thumb beyond the Foreword page and that too because the Foreword was written by a well known academician and Professor of history. The few books that the publisher gave me as complimentary remain in my bookshelf, slowly turning yellowish-brown with the fine dust that Delhi imports from the Rajasthan desert. The winter publication of this book has turned into a summer of discontent for me. I dread the fate of my next couple of books on Religious Harmony and Literary Essays as their audience will be limited to a small number of research scholars in Phiosophy and Literature.. My life story –Creative Truth-as I have titled it is meant for posterity and so currently it is so to say in a vault, kept concealed from inquisitive eyes.
I have no tangible evidence of anyone reading the stuff I dispense freely on my blog except what the statistics show as the number of page views of these blogs.  A slender part of these statistics is flattering but more often than not, the articles that I felt (in all modesty and humility) as my intellectual tour de force have scarcely received any hits. Maybe my writings often interspersed with literary quotations are not light reading stuff. Some of the blogs are long and may not interest the insta-blog readers.  Maybe the contents of the blogs particularly about WE, the people of India and about the steep decline of our political discourse make the readers uncomfortable and they would like the proverbial cat close their eyes to remain in the dark. How I wish I had received at least negative rejoinders than been humiliated and ignored for my pretentious claims to cerebral status! Disappointed over nil blog responses, I e-mailed a few select articles to some of my friends who have a passion for reading anything that comes their way in the hope of receiving their comments. But much to my distress, I did not receive even an acknowledgement of my mail giving rise to the fundamental question as to whom I write for. The second question ‘for whom do I write’ hurts while the first ‘Why do I write’ is baffling.
Let me try to find honest answers to the two questions- as to why and for whom do I write? Am I unique in subjecting myself to self inquisition? Or is this kind of self interrogation common to all writers like me who fail to make the writers’ grade? I cannot vouch for others, but I will be honest to admit being often racked with such questions that obliquely reflect the futility of my endeavour as a wordsmith. The incessant questioning as to why I write makes me skeptical about the worthwhileness of articulating my thoughts on paper. Do I write for others or do I write for my own pride and pleasure of creating something out of myself like a mother delivering her child? The labour pain of my writer’s cramp has been a waste in the absence of an appreciative audience; otherwise it should have given me the joy of creating a beautiful and interesting architecture of words.
I confess I have no audience. Someone to whom I confided my hurt pride was kind enough to suggest that I send them to the newspapers/newsmagazines for wider circulation. I tried quite a few times and the silence of the media was more devastating to my pride than the silence of the blog readers. In a polite manner by maintaining discreet silence, the media editors made me recognize the folly of approaching them with writings which in their view were substandard that cannot be seen in black and white in their newspapers/magazines.  Gone are the days when I used to get back my typed article with a polite letter of regret. But in this instamatic age, when e- mail has displaced the snail mail, I have to wait for a few days to understand that my article has been deleted from the editor’s mail-box. The silence of media today is so powerful as never to say anything that doesn't improve on silence. Since my self esteem would not allow me to accept my writings were sub standard, I often comfort myself by attributing  the rejection of my articles to my aam admi status that does not have the celebrity tag to ascend up the hallowed portals of the media.  
So the second question- for whom I write remains a question without an answer as no one really needs me to write for him/her. I am not a blue blooded writer and therefore I remain an orphan writer in search of adoption. And so to the question, why do I write? Though I am no Samuel Beckett, the Nobel laureate, his words ring true even for writers like me with no exceptional ability. Beckett , when asked about the nature of contemporary art  said: ‘…there is nothing to express, nothing with which to express, nothing from which to express, no power to express, no desire to express, together with the obligation to express.’ Writing is a compulsive act almost genetic for those who want to express even if there is nothing to express, who have a feel for the language even when there is nothing with which to express.  On the days I do not write, I feel emptiness within and a sense of one more wasted day especially when my days can be counted. The obligation to express is an obligation to myself, to weave a garland of words that would satisfy my artistic ego, to express as Wordsworth says ‘ the splendour in the grass and glory in the flower’ ,to lighten the burden of thoughts that weigh heavily on our hearts , to  let out the weight of emotions that lie too deep for tears and though last, but not the least, to experience  the pleasure of finding something ordinary in the extraordinary and something extraordinary in the ordinary. When one retires from active life, when one’s physique and athleticism are in the decline, the vitality of the mind becomes paradoxically intense as it has been fortified by  age-long life experiences.  I no longer  have the youthful subjectivity that gives rise to intensity and passion; instead age has brought with it  dispassionate objectivity that helps me to see into the life of things.  At this advanced period of my life I have no need for crystal gazing as the future is slowly regressing towards extinction. But the lens of the ageing mind has retained  a sharp focus  to see life with  crystal clarity. The essence of ageing is the experience of life in all its greatness and smallness.  It may sound incomprehensible and confounding that the springtime of the soul occurs in our wintry years when we begin to understand what freedom means-particularly the freedom of the mind. This is a blissful time when one is not subjected to personal and professional constraints that stifle the freedom of the mind. There is need to rein in the expression of ideas and thoughts distilled from life experiences  as there is no vested interest to be served. They are a partial record of a life in search of self understanding. The path to self knowledge- to know one self is through interpretation of life in all its myriad facets and through articulation of that discovery. I write for myself. If in the bargain my writings promote shared awareness and intellectual nourishment to the odd reader , I may  get a reprieve from charges of egotism and self indulgence.


Friday, 11 April 2014

Ruminations post polling




                                            Ruminations  post  polling
Yesterday was the voting day for us in Delhi.  The timing had been scheduled from 7 in the morning till 6 in the evening. Last time when the Delhi Assembly elections were held, we three-my husband, my daughter and I-  went around 2pm thinking that for Delhi-ites, it would be the siesta hour and therefore casting our votes  will be a quick and quiet job . To our surprise we found the queue was a mile long and we had to wait for two hours for our turn to ping the button. I had decided that this time we will be there at 7 am even though I knew as early birds we were unlikely to get any special worm.  I could not get to sleep the previous night lest I should fail to keep my 7am tryst at the voting booth. I woke up even before the darkness lifted and the twilight of the morning was visible. Knowing the reluctance of the other two to give up on their early morning sIeep I opened the windows- especially the ones that always opened with a thumping sound as though bullets were thudding them. By the time we got ready the sun had risen and there was nothing unusual about its rise. I recalled Samuel Beckett’s famous line: “The sun shone, having no alternative, on the nothing new.”
There was quietness in the neighbouring school where the booth was located for our colony. We were the first ones to arrive even as the policemen were yawning. It took us less than five minutes to come out properly inked on the left forefinger.  We have to wait for another five weeks to know if our votes had been for the winner or the loser. The cynic in me chortled for I knew and as all others knew that whosoever be the winner, it would make no difference to the voters. Life will proceed just the same way as before once the election frenzy gets muted till such time when the next elections will take place- five years or even less than that.
We are residents of south Delhi  whose voters  comprise  the affluent and the upper middle classes in posh colonies, the lower  middle class in government colonies, the average middle classes in Delhi Development Authority’s housing apartments along with a large number of Muslims in the old poorly developed localities dotting the borders of the well heeled communities and the adjacent lower class colonies consisting of  one and two room tenements . The canvassing this time was on a low key and unlike the December Delhi elections, even the text messages on the mobiles were few and far between.  I learnt later that there were no long queues at any point of time- again a contrast with what we had seen in December ( though the media report is to the contrary)

It is difficult to discern any voting pattern in these assorted groups except for what one reads in the newspapers and views on the TV channels besides what the bookies offer. It is foolish and naïve to think that the parties in the election fray have a magic wand to dispel gloom and despondency that had gripped the minds of most people and that it will all be hunky-dory after a new party takes over. India is too vast a country to be governed both in terms of space and numbers. Governance is as difficult to understand as rocket science needing both remarkable intelligence and ability. There has been a steady decline in governance and administration after the first few years of the Nehruvian era and it has hit the lowest depths in the last two decades. Three different parties battling on the electoral ground have pitched high their strength and their resolve to give good governance in their manifestoes. The fledgling AAP promises to rid the country of corruption, the BJP promises spring in the air with decisive leadership and the oldest GOP promises to fulfill people’s fundamental rights to health and pension and empowerment of the weaker sections. But none of the three have provided a hint of how they will realize their promises as they know that fulfilling them is like catching a leviathan in a fly net.  Corruption today has become a part of our DNA, democracy cannot accept unilateral leadership and inclusive development is more of a mirage than reality.

What ails our nation? What ails our much vaunted democracy? The simple and straightforward answer is We, the people of India. Corruption as alleged by AAP and by BJP whenever the latter wanted to train its guns on the party in power is not the monopoly of the politicians. The AAP’s tarring of politicians of all stripes sparing their own party has given greater license to the rest of the people of India to indulge in sly and covert underhand dealings because they are not the target of attack of those who are in power and who bid for power. Corruption has to be viewed as a double headed hydra as both the bribe giver and the bribe taker contribute to our present venal society. To avoid paying a few extra rupees on sales tax, we tell the shopkeeper not to make the bill which suits him equally. The trader-customer dishonesty is a daily and ubiquitous happening. We go to any length to conceal our income to avoid paying income tax. We , the clerks and babus in government offices make short shrift of the innumerable requests of fellow Indians for gas and power connections, for making alterations in their homes, for water supply, for delivery of essential municipal services including health and education, for resolving public grievances  etc unless we swell their purses. It is a standard joke that we need to grease the wheels of our applications to make them move from one desk to another and to be satisfactorily resolved at the highest desk in the municipal offices. We, the fruit and vegetable vendors sell poor quality to our fellow citizens at astronomical price even as we make money by exporting choice agricultural products to the rich class and to NRIs abroad. We, the teachers are either absent from the class or when present provide sub standard lessons to students expecting them to come home for tuition to pass the examinations. We, the doctors prescribe unnecessary multiple diagnostic tests and scans at clinics and laboratories from where we  would  in turn receive a part  of the  exorbitant fees to be paid for such investigations in those diagnostic centres.  We, the engineers in cahoots with contractors and building material suppliers do not mind risking the safety of fellow beings by using inferior material in constructing their houses. We, the Administrators go for larger sums for awarding contract and for effecting land deals from the poor farmers and villagers. We, the ‘jugad’ experts make huge profit by producing spurious medicines, illicit alcohol, deadly drugs and crude bombs with no concern for the lives of our fellow citizens. We, the police refuse to file a FIR or act for the security of the citizens unless our palms are oiled. The list is endless and so the AAP’s target of the politicians to win the hearts of the other bribers is naïve if not trickery. Karl Kraus said: “ Corruption is worse than prostitution. The latter might endanger the morals of an individual; the former invariably endangers the morals of the entire country.”
 
 Democracy for India has been good as it had stopped fuelling dictatorship that had been the case with our western neighbor. It has stayed its course for the last 66 years except for a brief 21 month period in the mid-‘70s. Indira Gandhi had to revoke emergency as democratic India refused to yield to her authoritarian rule by decree, allowing elections to be suspended and civil liberties to be curbed. From that experience, it is clear that We, the people of India will be hard put to accept a strong leader who has not displayed the gentler and democratic aspect of his personality during the last 16 years of his tenure as Chief Minister of Gujarat. Thomas Jefferson had once warned the Americans that “Consolidation of power in one individual is a threat to democracy and will lead to corruption, its necessary consequence.

But in our love for democracy that confers on us freedom of speech and action, freedom to enjoy the fundamental rights provided in the Constitution, we have forgotten that duties come before rights. To the above list of our acts of corruption, we the people of India have added corruption of the mind and spirit. Indiscipline is endemic among us and is seen in every walk of life. We, the early morning walkers , walk three abreast on a narrow garden  path that is wide enough to accommodate just one person. We push aside the lone aged walker and stride past him/her without so much as a ‘sorry, please’. We spit on the road, we throw garbage on the road, we pride in jumping the lights at crossings, we hoot and drive roughshod over others, we scream “No queues for us ;we are Indians” and refuse to line up- in short, we are woefully negligent with regard to minimal courtesy and duty by fellow citizens.  Duty is a social force that binds us to the course of actions demanded by that force. Both our  demanding our rights and the political parties wooing the voters with concession to those demands are maladroit acts . As a democratic nation we have failed to understand  Rockefeller’s statement that “Every right implies a responsibility; every opportunity, an obligation; every possession, a duty"
 In a thought provoking article on  Nadella as Microsoft CEO: A Slap in the Face for Indian System,  the writer Jagannathan points out how our democratic system encourages talkers than doers and how our argumentative and democratic nature stops with running down people and not solving any problems. AAP’s approach has been clearly on these lines. The rise of one individual as a leader like Jayalalitha in Chennai, Mamta in WestBengal, Patnaik in Odisha and Narendra Modi in Gujarat reveal the bankruptcy of our democratic spirit.  Earlier it was Indira Gandhi. The  personality cult around which the power is now built bodes ill for a vibrant democracy. Jagannathan recognizes that the innate flaw of democracy in India lies in  its inability to tolerate success. This  has been the bane of our system:  “Our system kills initiative rather than engender it. We want pliable yes-men and non-achievers around us, not non-conformists and people with ideas of their own.”
We have cast our votes as democratic citizens of India. The media has gone bonkers with their mindless coverage of speeches of leaders that are empty of ideas and full of venom and hatred. It has covertly campaigned in favour of authoritarian leadership on the one hand and cleansing of the augean task of reforming politics and democracy in the country. What has been set in motion is chaos and confusion with grandstanding about empowerment and change.
I voted for the first time nearly half a decade ago in 1962. Jawaharlal Nehru was then voted back to power for a third time. Those elections had still the remnants of Indian nationalism and Gandhian idealism . As we now approach the 16th Lok Sabha, we cannot ignore the depths to which we as a nation have fallen. I wish the new Lok Sabha elects people of reputation, of spotless integrity and selfless dedication to steer the country out of the moral morass that we have created for ourselves. As I returned home from the polling booth, these lines from Shakespeare’s Richard II echoed through my mind as though by its repetition I could still hope that we the people of India  have discharged our duty and responsibility for a positive mandate.
                                                         My dear, dear Lord,
                                                   The purest treasure mortal times afford
                                                    is spotless reputation; that away
                                                    Men are but gilded loan or painted clay...
                                                    Mine honor is my life; both grow in one;
                                                   Take honor from me, and my life is done.”







Thursday, 3 April 2014

Authority, Anarchy and Intellectual Pragmatism



                                             Authority, Anarchy and Intellectual Pragmatism
Orhan Pamuk , the Nobel  Laureate from Turkey writes: “ When we see that other writers have had experiences similar to our own, we are inspired not just to read but to write and most particularly, to explore the differences.”.  When I read his piece on Traffic and Religion that discusses the tendency among drivers in Tehran to circumvent the traffic rules, I saw the similarity of disobeying the rules of the road in our own country. Pamuk says that this tendency is the same as the tendency among many in Tehran to circumvent the Sharia in the privacy of their homes.
When the roads are clear and there is no traffic from the opposite side, we often wonder if the one way traffic signal should be followed strictly or should one take the forward lunge and zoom through! If there is an empty road, it seems a trifle foolish to stop at the red signal and wait for it to turn green. This dilemma spotlights the perennial clash between intellectual pragmatism and obedience to authority.  If we discard the ‘No entry-one way’ signal and move ahead, we fear that we may- even if we are not caught on the CCTV camera- end up with head on collision with the vehicle from the opposite side and it is this that makes us wonder whether to be governed by intellectual pragmatism or by the rule of authority.
I mused over the phrase ‘intellectual pragmatism’ and realized the unleashing of                                anarchy if we as individuals collectively subscribe to ignoring the rules on the wise perceptions of practicality.  Rules are mandated to prevent traffic anarchy. But what is to be done when rules do not factor in intellectual pragmatism and mock at our imagination and thinking faculty. 
It was a Eureka moment for me when I suddenly hit upon an equation
Authority-intellectual Pragmatism= Anarchy
I tried to validate this equation in respect of the innumerable daily occurrences. Before I do so, let me clarify that Authority is not just the faceless authority of the Government or the Dictator or the ruling establishment; it also includes religious authority, parental authority, male authority, institutional authority, the clerical authority(in all government offices),the management authority, the media authority(that adopts a hectoring tone to quiz the lambs on their TV shows)- in short authority of any kind. No one can claim to be free of the rule of some Authority –not even if he is a Prime Minister or a Dictator or  a Corporate giant because the big brother Media and the Judiciary are watching  each and every action and in particular the actions of omission and commission of those who are leaders in their own right.
Authority everywhere claims to be self righteous as the impartial voice of law, but in reality it often uses its power and privilege to tweak the law as the situation demands. The Scottish proverb says “Show me the man and I will show you the law” is not an empty aphorism but a reality. It has the power to protect as well as the power to destroy a person and his/her reputation. An intellectual Pragmatist (IP) understands this and stays true to the course in his wisdom. Pragmatism that grew up after Darwin’s Theory of evolution insists on the belief that chance rather than providence guides human affairs, and that persistent adherence to established authority will lead to violence.  Kloppenberg who wrote about Obama the Pragmatist says that ‘Pragmatism maintains that people are constantly devising and updating ideas to navigate the world in which they live; it embraces open-minded experimentation and continuing debate. It is a philosophy for skeptics, not true believers’.  So when the IP is confronted with inane and arcane authority, his intelligence conflicts with his sense of loyalty and adherence to the rule of law.  Casting aside his hesitation to go counter to established Authority he rebels and in his rebellion sows the first seed of anarchy. He looks at Authority as coercive and gradually spreads the ideal of anarchy by enlisting individuals and groups as the principal mode of organized society to overthrow it. 
We see the growing tendency towards anarchy in contemporary society as it is attractive to live in the absence of any cohesive principle or any form of authority. It thrills the aam admi to don the robes of David and fight an imaginary Goliath as he considers all forms of authority to be demonic and draconian. It seems normal for a youth in his/her adolescence to rebel against parental authority that does not take into account the changed practicality of contemporary life. Respect for authority- be it parental or institutional or for the Guru – is demeaning for the youth who has a mistaken notion of being an intellectual pragmatist. The youth priding himself as a skeptic prefers to be dictated by his personal predilection than submit himself to the established wisdom of the earlier era founded upon tradition which he feels authoritarian. The Maoist killing of the police and security forces is another instance of intellectual pragmatism going awry as it is devoid of any intelligent approach to relieve poverty haunting the tribals, the poor and the lowly in different parts of the country. So are the religious genocides in response to a group’s religious fanaticism without any intellectual tolerance and pragmatism resulting in death, grief and misery to millions of people. The Khap Panchayat’s diktat of sanctioning honour killing goes against intellectual pragmatism that upholds the validity of love between a man and a woman belonging to different castes/religions/class. The surest recipe for anarchy is to misunderstand intellectual pragmatism as a license to follow one’s own perception and not be bound by any cohesive principle or order that makes for a stable society. Similarly the surest way of ushering in anarchy is for the Authority to ignore intellectual pragmatism. Those who call themselves anarchists can neither practice intellectual pragmatism nor exercise authority.
Authority has to have a human face. It can enforce people to obey its rules and regulations, pay theirr bills and taxes, observe fundamental principles of law and order provided these mandates do not skirt the problems they may hold for the majority. Intellectual pragmatism is the protective armour around Authority and Authority risks ignoring it at its own peril.  Similarly intellectual pragmatism cannot ignore Authority without descending to anarchy. The two need each other to fend off anarchy.