Tuesday, 1 July 2014

Faculty Recruitment: Alignment between Individual Merit and Institutional Excellence

       Faculty Recruitment: Alignment between Individual Merit and Institutional Excellence

The Minister of HRD has announced setting up IITs in every state. There has been a volley of protests from many IITians about the need to set up new institutes when the older ones have problems finding good faculty to teach and research. This is not an isolated problem with IITs. All major Central universities and colleges affiliated to them are also in a quandary as to how to fill up the vacancies that exist. The present minister, Smriti Irani is on the same line with the earlier Minister Kapil Sibal in finding quick-fix solutions to higher education issues by promising to open more and more institutes as though the increase in the number of Institutes alone will help India qualify as a knowledge hub.  
In fact the main issue before our higher education institutions is one of reconciling the two imponderables- quality with quantity. In their eagerness to please the public, all politicians take recourse to expansion by starting new institutes and universities to accommodate all students aspiring for admission. Institutions are built and not opened like shops for the public to enter and buy from the variety of goods stacked in the shelves. Even if the shop is attractively designed and stocked with all the latest products available but has poor salespersons, the shop loses its attraction for the customers. This is equally true of all educational institutions- from schools to colleges to universities and other degree awarding institutes such as the Institutes of Technology and Management. The setting up of new educational institutions is like opening shops with plush interiors, stacking the syllabus shelf with course designs culled from universities in the West, constructing state-of the -art laboratories but without proper faculty to teach. The existing colleges in the University of Delhi alone have a backlog of vacancies to be filled up. The process involved is cumbersome and colleges short circuit it by making haphazard ad -hoc appointments that can last only for three months. The short tenure of the ad-hoc teachers affects the quality of instruction and ad- hoc appointees cannot be held accountable for the poor performance of the students. 
Colleges are wary of the selection process that has to go through many stages before the interviews take place. The colleges have to seek the permission of the University Grants Commission (as it holds the purse strings of the colleges) to fill vacancies as and when they arise. The UGC will ask one of its junior assistants to do a mathematical calculation as per the teacher-student ratio of 1:12 (for Hons course) and 1;15 (for pass courses) and  accordingly grant or withhold its approval. There are language courses like Sanskrit, Bengali, Tamil and other regional languages besides courses in Philosophy, Mathematics, Geography etc where the intake of students will be less though the number of papers to be studied in these courses is the same as for other honours courses. The mathematical calculation in the case of such departments will be naturally skewed as the ratio of teacher to students will be low making it impossible to get a faculty of full strength to teach all the papers spread over three years. For example if there is a strength of ten students in a language honours course, as per the present teacher-student ratio, only one teacher can be appointed , raising the question how that single teacher can handle all the prescribed papers . This process of quantification and ratiocination through arithmetical calculation is thus deeply flawed as it fails to factor in the number of papers to be taught.                                                                                                                                          
The selection committee is constituted by the University comprising two university experts, the Chairperson of the Management Committee, the teacher-in- charge of the department and the principal of the college. On paper, this sounds reasonable and just, but the Chairperson who invariably belongs to the party in power gives his nod to the person recommended by the party higher-ups. In most of the selections, merit becomes the casualty yielding its rightful position to party sponsored nepotism. Since the Chairperson’s approval is needed (and inter alia, the patronage of the political party), the selection committee often kowtows to him/her.  The constitution of the selection committee needs a re-look wherefore   it has no member other than subject experts of proven rectitude. The advertisement to these posts should also be unambiguously clear, identifying the area that is to be taught. For example a history position should state whether it is for ancient history or medieval or modern, European or American or Far-east so that the experts on the Selection Committee are specialists in that area. A position in Botany should specify if it is for Bio- technology or Genomics or Molecular Biology etc. Vague generalization will make it easy for manipulation and devious management of the selection process. Similarly the professors always try to appoint students working under them. The common line of argument is if the difference among the top candidates is minimal, it is better to select one among them who is personally known to the professors who can vouch for their calibre. Again this has led to academic favouritism and partisanship in the selection and appointment of teachers. It is important for the applicant to state the names of the Professors s/he has worked under so that they do not become a part of the selection committee. It will be prudent to have a list of experts outside of the university/college that has advertised for the academic positions.
The third problem arises out of reservation posts.    For instance, the posts falling against the 7th, 15th, and 20th points in the roster are reserved for the Scheduled Castes; the posts falling against the 4th, 8th, 12th, and 16th for the Other Backward Classes; posts falling against 14th, 28th and 40th for the Scheduled Tribes and so on until 200 points are reached in the roster, by which time Scheduled Castes would have got 30 posts (i.e. 15% of 200), Scheduled Tribes 15 posts (i.e. 7.5% for 200), and the Other Backward Classes 54 posts (i.e. 27% of 200). Here comes an important question. Should academic positions have reservations? While reservation is welcome at different levels of administration, reservation in teaching fails to address two issues-(1) the quality of a teacher is to be determined by merit and not by caste because teaching demands a reasonable degree of mastery over the subject and good communication skills. (2) Unlike administrative jobs where on the job training can be given, academic positions are post-learning jobs. When a soldier enters the battle field for the first time, we call it ‘baptism by fire’. The soldier undergoes enormous training before he is inducted into the battle field. Similarly a teacher has to have an in-depth understanding of his/her subject before s/he is inducted into the classroom. There is no luxury of on-the-job training for a teacher as is the case with the soldier.  Handling young sensitive minds, initiating them into the higher realms of knowledge, perking up their cognitive curiosity and raising the bar of learning are core  intellectual tasks that can be accomplished only by those  who have an aptitude for learning and who have attained a reasonable degree of scholarship. Teaching is not a practical job; it needs mental discipline and a love for intellectual pursuits. All applicants including the reserved category have to go through this grind before they are eligible to apply for a teaching position. If one has a natural talent, aptitude and ability for intellectual and academic pursuits, s/he joins the academic position. This is to be done only on merit. It will be a pity to see anyone enter an academic career on quota and not by merit that denies him the true worth of the knowledge he has acquired. What I have written will not sound politically correct but if quality, dignity and intellectual worth of the applicant are to be respected, merit alone warrants attention.
These are basic steps to be followed in the recruitment process. But the greater problem is the acute shortage of high quality teachers with a zest for knowledge and continuous scholarship. The Tamil proverb that you can ladle that which is in the pot is applicable to all our higher educational institutions. The number of available candidates with high research scholarship is far too small given the huge backlog of vacancies to be filled. In order of preference, teaching profession occupies the lowest for our young men and women who graduate with distinction. In the past, the IIT ians formed the largest exodus in search of greener pastures in the West. We now witness our best students leaving for US through SAT examination even before graduation. They go for their first degree in Sciences or Humanities to top US universities and do not return as the scope for research and academic pursuits are far more satisfying there in terms of intellectual and monetary gains. The American universities in particular encourage and reward merit without discrimination.  The other options for our bright young graduates are to go for a Management degree from top IIMs and become the highest paid corporate professionals where they have seamless opportunities for advanced career graph. A few among them with commitment and dedication opt for civil services where merit often finds itself in a losing competition with extraneous pressure groups. Academics is the last refuge of our bright young minds when all other options are closed to them. Dispirited and depressed, they enter the academic profession that neither fetches them a handsome pay packet nor a premier status in society. The very few who persist with academics despite all its downsides and disadvantages establish themselves as scholars of international repute. We have to be thankful that we have such noteworthy academicians in our universities even if they constitute a very small percentage of the available faculty. But we need a lot more of such high quality scholars in our institutions to carry on indigenous research and generate ideas that are germane to the development of our society. The question is where can they be found and how can they be assured that our institutions of higher learning are places where excellence is law.  
This requires rebooting the process of recruitment that is to be solely based on the highest academic credentials of the candidate. To attract the best minds, our institutions should spread its net wide across the world and not limit it to what is available within the country. We must have the humility to acknowledge that the academic rigour in the developed countries is far more potent than anything that we have in India. While not denying the advantages the universities in the West have in terms of infrastructure, state-of-the art laboratories, libraries, and academic ambience in general, the significant aspect to be noted is the encouragement given to brilliant scholars to pursue research in terms of funding and facilities they require. Laboratories and libraries are open till late hours at night and give freedom to scholars to work without disturbance. On- campus accommodation is a great help giving them easy access to the labs and libraries from their residences. Unless this academic rigour is injected into our universities, getting the best minds to return and retaining the best minds in the country (without their making a beeline to the West) will remain a distant dream.
It may be difficult to match a professor’s emoluments in the West with what our institutions can offer. It may be prudent to get some of the best Indian faculty from abroad to teach a year or two on enhanced pay packet and seek their assistance to set up laboratories and Study Centres to train our young men and women in advanced research in our universities. There is nothing infra dig if we invite the best minds- both Indian and international- to reinvigorate our universities and provide renewed impetus to academic regeneration.  Instead of spending money on new IITs and new universities, the existing institutions can be funded to develop them to be compatible with any university or centre of excellence in any part of the world. In this way the academic ambience can be nurtured and universities can gain international exposure. The faculty recruitment will attract the best minds if the pay packet is almost on par with what an IIM graduate is offered at the start of his career. Recruitment for university position has to focus only on academic merit and on parameters that reflect the applicant’s aptitude for sustained research and learning. Universities should look for scholars with “cluster initiative,” which encourages scholarly and academic collaboration across disciplines and also addresses the problem of critical mass within a particular candidate’s field of interest.
Universities that are the highest altar of learning cannot accommodate puerile democratization and be open to the entry of one and all. Universities are to be distinguished from all other institutions and be allowed to restrict entry to those who devote themselves to the pursuit and spread of organized knowledge. Throughout human history, the evolution of life and civilization has depended on the generation of new ideas, thoughts and philosophy.  University education encourages innovative research and new knowledge to meet the challenges of an evolving world which never rests content on fossilized theories and concepts. Universities are thus meant to be the preserves for higher human alternatives. Excellence of the kind that we associate with Universities is different. It is intellectual and philosophical as it is humane learning. Developing cultivated minds that can harmonize and synthesise different thoughts and ideas and promoting civilized citizenship constitute excellence in university education. It will be incorrect to equate excellence in professional institutions with excellence in university education. We need both. They do not conflict with each other; rather they enrich and enhance learning and contribute to a qualitative change in all our existential dimensions. True excellence aggregates around the most urgent questions we face as humans. In this essential pursuit of excellence, universities may have to seek new rules and regulations for faculty recruitment that may on the surface conflict with social equity and  incur the odium of elitism, but in the long run such elitism if understood in its true spirit will permit scholars and intellectuals to possess and cultivate superior talent to benefit the most disadvantaged sections of the society.
.

Tuesday, 24 June 2014

FYUP- the Myth and the Reality

                                                 FYUP- the Myth and the Reality

It is a pity that a major debate on FYUP is not attempted on its academic worth but is used  only to settle scores politically. It is in keeping with the present trend of packaging everything into politics instead of looking at issues on a comparative analysis of their merits and demerits. The controversy that has erupted over FYUP is divided on political lines and steers clear of discussing its advantages over the conventional three year degree programmes. Students under the banner of different political parties have raised their voices demanding a roll back of the FYUP without giving one single reason for making such a demand. Burning effigies, shouting slogans and even assaulting teachers who are pro FYUP are exciting for them especially when the TV crews are in large numbers to beam live the agitation through their channels. I have not seen any single argument against FYUP except that the programme has to be rolled back in the interest of the students. There is no one among the protesting students  group to put the finger on its drawback except that there will be a wait of one more year to get their first degree and that means  delay in starting to earn alongside incurring  additional expenditure on university fees, and for the hostellers, on boarding and lodging for an extra year. The students have not bothered to educate themselves on the possible plusses of FYUP but indulge in a blanket negation of the course as unsuited for them. The teachers who protest against it are angry because they were not consulted in structuring the course and are upset that the University thrust a half baked syllabus for the Foundation course without any input from their side. Here also these teachers do not debate the crux of the issue- “why and why not FYUP.” Even those who are on the side of FYUP do not indulge in a reasoned debate on its merits.
The political parties love to fish in troubled waters especially if the yield on the vote banks is likely to be high. The pre election campaign dubbed the FYUP as the Congress brainchild that has to be dumped for that reason alone. With Delhi elections a few months away, the BJP, AAP and the Congress outrival each other in their blind opposition to FYUP sensing that a majority of the stakeholders are against it. If academics fail to debate issues on merit, how can we expect the political parties not to turn a rational issue on its head and make it emotive? The BJP spokesman pontificates that “We have been continuously opposing the four year course because I think the three year course is something that serves the university students better.” But “how” is a question that is neither raised nor answered. AAP is on record that it will abolish FYUP- though no reason has been given for its animus. Congress that had remained silent when FYUP was introduced has realized its mistake of remaining silent and in its bid to regain its lost ground has allowed its youth wing to protest against FYUP. In fact, the Ministry of HRD must  have recommended the DU Vice-Chancellor for Padma Shri for his innovative reforms and has now dumped him  for the very same reason. But none of them has one single rational argument as to why three year course is better than the four year course. Media men and women, anchors on TV channels and the same select group of intellectuals invited for discussion end up with a cacophony of voices that makes reason and FYUP the leading casualty.
 So what is FYUP and why has DU ‘thrust’ it on unwilling teachers and students? FYUP is an extension of undergraduate course for a  fourth year in order to provide time and  intellectual space for the students to get exposed to a wide array of disciplines other than the one in which he seeks to major. Gone are the days when students studied stand-alone disciplines to the total ignorance of all other areas of knowledge.  A student of humanities knew nothing about new trends in science and technology and a student of science hardly knew sociology or economics or literature. Unless a scientist understands society and human social behavior, especially the study of the origins, organization, institutions, and development of human society, his contribution to science will be a self contained effort with no relevance to society as a whole. When Physics and Philosophy are coming closer, it is unfortunate that students of Humanities do not have the basic knowledge of quantum physics or the Higgs particle also known as God’s particle. The Foundation courses are meant to fill this lacuna in higher education and qualitatively improve learning. Also the Discipline II course introduced at the FYUP is meant to provide students an opportunity to pursue in depth a second discipline other than the one he seeks to major in. The FYUP provides for the option to leave at the end of three years with a BA degree or study for one more year to get a Honours degree. So the three year degree is a part of the FYUP and why all this fuss?
Quality of higher education is assured in two ways through FYUP: (1) a holistic, inter disciplinary approach to learning (2) Those who pursue four years have the distinct advantage of studying in depth two disciplines and going for higher research in any one of them. The Masters  programme is reduced from two to one year—where the level and intensity of lectures will be high and students will be asked to do more self learning and write a dissertation as a part of examination requirement. This will be a qualitative high for University education.
What is urgently required is restructuring of the Foundation courses to provide holistic and interesting learning for the students.  I had suggested in a number of my writings that seminal books on each discipline can be prescribed and eminent professors within the colleges and outside of the colleges can be requested to lecture on them to make students understand the different and yet linked strands of various disciplines. To discard FYUP because of the current poorly structured Foundation course is a retrograde step.
As for the peripheral issues raised by sloganeering students and political parties about an additional year that would deprive the three year degree holder of prospective employment, less said the better. The current degree holders even after their Masters degree have obtained no employable skills as the degrees are degrees by rote and not degrees of learning.  For the other objection about fees for the additional year, DU’s charges are 18/ per month  that amounts to 216/ for a year. If boarding, lodging and other charges are taken into account it must be remembered that whether the student is   back home or stays in a hostel or PG accommodation, the difference will not  be that enormous. DU charges are pittance compared to private universities who advertise their tie- ups with foreign universities ( subtly hinting that Indian degrees are inferior). If DU is ambitious to introduce daring reforms for qualitative improvement, is it too much to ask for additional expenditure of an affordable sum?
Let there be an academic debate on the advantages/ disadvantages of FYUP. To discard it without a rational debate is to discard something valuable in the eagerness to get political mileage out of it. Instead of packaging politics into academics , we in India are packaging academics into politics.

Monday, 23 June 2014

Talk the Talk:




                                       An Open Letter to the Hon’ble Prime Minister of India
                                                                      Talk the Talk
I address this letter not as your acolyte nor as your critic but as a citizen of India who shares the concerns of many fellow citizens on issues that are vital to the nation’s social, economic and spiritual growth and development. Today is exactly a month since you moved into the South Block. Many including me were pleasantly surprised to see a ‘modi’-fied Prime Minister different from the PM-in-waiting before the polls. Gone was the vitriolic demagoguery that characterized your election campaign. The humungous mandate given to you brought out the softer side of your personality to welcome the modicum of opposition to join you in rebuilding the nation. I salute you for the graciousness you displayed in your address to the Parliament though you had the huge mandate to brush aside and crush the opposition.
But the issues that your party men have raised over the last four weeks are not a part of the 100days agenda you had set for your ministries. These issues are not that important to precede other pressing issues you had enlisted as a fulfillment of your campaign promises on development and decisive leadership. You have chosen to remain silent (though you used to refer to the earlier PM as Maun Mohan Singh) on issues that do not have any earthshaking urgency to be decided now. You have a full five years to go and if I remember your first statement on becoming the PM that you are not a one-term PM- which means you have a good 10 years to take decisions on non- sequitar  issues that do not follow your development agenda and issues that are volatile and inflammable and therefore can remain in the backburner till the time is ripe to let them out.  One suspects whether the PM’s chair generates a current of silence that short circuits decisive leadership.  Otherwise why do  you remain silent and not take decisive steps to stop your minions from gabbing too soon and without a care for the consequences? If the chair is not the cause, then I presume it is a planned strategy though it is difficult to imagine an experienced politician like you to rush into emotive and risky territories before the ink on your acceptance document has dried.
Two days into taking charge of his ministry, the MOS in your PM’s office, Jitendra Singh said that the process of abrogating Article 370 has begun. This is a highly emotive issue and threatens to develop into a mighty conflagration reminiscent of the street battles that erupted in Kashmir in 2008. A debate about it is certainly in the interest of the integration of J&K with the rest of India, but it is not an urgent issue to debate now.  This can wait – if it had waited this long –as there has been till now no solution to India-Pakistan dispute over the state. When your core agenda had been growth and good governance, do we need to start this debate that may help communal forces to raise their fiery heads? You who have proved to be a man of words,  would have done well to rein in your MOS and assured your countrymen that all these issues can wait as your primary attention is to fulfill your promises on development. You were not voted to power on the issue of Article 370 which is limited to Jammu and Kashmir. Why have you chosen to remain silent?
The second contentious issue has been raised by Radha Man Singh on Uniform Civil Code. This is again a sensitive issue and you have chosen to remain impassive and not pull up your minister for the unseemly haste of raising such an explosive issue. However it is reassuring to listen to your interview with a Urdu daily Nai Dhunia saying that implementation of UCC does not mean that Hindu code will be imposed on all citizens of the country. But how many have access to the Urdu daily and why choose that instead of giving a press release to all the newspapers?
 The third issue on which you have remained silent except for a cryptic statement in the Parliament that you feel sad over  the brutal murder of a Muslim techie – one who had no connection with the Facebook derogatory depiction of Shivaji and Bal Thackeray. Can you remain silent without issuing a warning and a condemnation of the fringe parties that are raising their ugly majoritarian heads and resorting to covert ways to frighten the Muslims? Your remaining silent has given a lot of confidence to those who want to prove more loyal than the king. Are  you be a BJP version of Maun Mohan Singh allowing things to drift and come to a pass where everyone takes law into his hands to speak and act as he wills- an art that is perfected and practiced by your alliance partner Shiv Sena in Mumbai.
The next one is the issue of language. Is this the time to start a language controversy?  By suddenly letting loose the language genie from the bottle where it had lain for the last 50 odd years, aren’t you stoking a controversy that has no relevance in today’s world? Maybe it is Rajnath Singh and his deputy who have started the language ball rolling, but shouldn’t you stop it from getting lost in a battle of Babels? There are two basic problems with this directive to impose language only in Hindi speaking states on social media communications. Social media is the social interaction among people in which they create, share or exchange information and ideas in virtual communities and networks. Does this mean that Hindi speaking people can share and exchange information in Hindi only among themselves and not with the rest of India? Doesn’t this create a divide between North India and South India?  Yet another point is you were voted to power by addressing to the needs of the aspirationsof the  youth of India. This mandatory circular (even if restricted to Hindi belt) of postings in Hindi is a retrograde step in fulfilling the aspirations of our youth.  Even today a large exodus of our bright young men and women to US and the West is taking place. English is a link language with the world outside and if perceptions become the truth, such unnecessary thrust on Hindi may drive away many  many more of our aspiring youths to seek foreign shores.
The calls emanating from the PMO to governors and heads of many organizations to resign are in bad taste. Again it is a covert way of pressurising the appointees of the earlier government without putting anything in writing lest they should go to the highest court of the land that had given judgement that removal is legal only if there are valid reasons of misconduct or criminal proceedings pending against these appointees. The wind of fresh graciousness that breezed through your address in Parliament seems to have been blown away by the vendetta storm. You have your compulsions to accommodate the 75+ disgruntled members of your party in some gubernatorial offices. But this can also wait as some of them may have their tenure over in a few months. The heads of National Disaster Management Authority, ICCR etc have been asked to resign. Why? Even if you have to oblige some of your party members jostling for such positions, you can appoint them as Co-heads so that the transition is smooth and does not smack of vendetta against all erstwhile government appointees.
Last but not the least is the Four Year Undergraduate programmes flagged off by University of Delhi last year.  Suffice it to say, the silence of your young minister and the clever manipulation of the UGC do not lend credibility to your government. No one wants to indulge in an academic rational debate about the usefulness of Foundation courses and Discipline II courses that have required an additional year to the existing three year course. The Foundation courses are broad based and give the student an inclusive understanding of subjects other than the one that he has chosen to major in. This is in keeping with the much sought after Liberal Arts courses in the West including Hongkong University to bridge the divide between Arts and Sciences. The objective is to expose the student to Shakespeare as well as to the laws of Thermodynamics. This is inter-disciplinary in nature and is useful for a broader understanding of disciplines that have an interrelated bearing on our everyday life. It helps the students who are given the right to vote at the age of 18 to debate, analyze and critique issues and develop  into a responsible citizen of the country and by extension a citizen of the world. It is unfortunate that the University of Delhi has not designed and structured these courses to make them interesting, informative and inclusive for the students. This can be done and restructuring of the courses can take place now. Further to keep in mind your promise of reducing unemployment, this additional one year in the University with added skill training may prove beneficial to you.
Allied to this controversy is the UGC trying to create a wedge between colleges and the University. Delhi Colleges are constituent colleges of the University and follow the resolutions passed by the Acdemic and the Executive Councils. The  UGC had dispatched messengers on a Sunday afternoon with its letter to each of the 70 colleges of Delhi University threatening them with stoppage of grants if they did not revert to three year programme by Monday but toed the University decision to continue with the FYUP. Should colleges be made pawns in the fight between the University and the Government? Again why is the Minister silent and has asked the UGC  instead to do the bullying? May I ask you, Hon’ble Prime minister, why are you silent? There are many promises made in your pre-poll manifesto and this issue is one of them . It may be  xpedient for the BJP to derail FYUP to garner the votes in the coming Delhi elections – votes of the students who are not aware of the significance of Liberal Arts programme  ingrained in the Foundation courses.   It will be salutary in the interest of Higher education if the University is asked to allow students the choice to opt for three years or four years of UG studies  so that those who do a four year course alone will be eligible for admission  to one year Masters course. The worthwhileness of any change is to be measured in terms of quality output and the challenges it offers to the student. The pandering to the students’ whim  to revert to three year UG course –which has no rational argument to support- is going against the needs and aspirations of the youth today.

One more point. You are now the much sought after Prime Minister. US has invited you to address both the Houses. Well, Kindly pardon me if I say that the invitation is to the Indian PM and not to you in your  personal capacity. US does not want to lose its potential ally for trade and business and so they have bitten the bullet with reference to you. The only point you have to remember is this high priority status given by US to India is the result of years of work done by the government from which you have freed India. You are reaping the fruits that are the yield of the seeds planted and nurtured by the party and its leaders you have your own reasons to dislike.
Usually everyone will request you and look to you to walk the talk. I request you to talk the talk and not remain Moun like your distinguished predecessor. Lastly I would request you to stop complaining about Congress whenever you have to administer bitter pills towards ache din. You have allowed the rise in railway fares before the rail Budget is to be presented- something that you flayed the then PM as being unethical. Where  have these ethics gone? Kindly talk the talk you have made famous during the election campaign and not walk the talk of your predecessors.