Monday, 19 May 2014

Finding My Voice



Amidst the euphoria surrounding the arrival of the new ‘Desh Rakhvala, there have been three brilliant articles – two of them in the Hindu and the third one in the Times of India. The first one ( as it appeared before the other two) deals with urgent reforms needed in the Congress,  the second proffers  sound advice to the PM-designate and the third sees  Cultural Revenge on Liberal  humanists in this stupendous victory of Modi. All three speak not much about the BJP victory as the victory of the new Indian Lincoln whose march to 7 RCR  is similar to the great American’s march to the white House from the log cabin.
These articles have helped me to recover from stupefaction over the drubbing Congress got in the recently concluded elections. A party with a 125 year legacy is now shrunk to just 44 seats in the 543 Lok Sabha.  I had decided to hang my pen( rather  my laptop)and  abjure my passionate canvassing for a leader worthy of India , for a Philosopher-King, for a  cultured, educated , decent, dynamic statesman  who speaks the language of intellect and not emotion, who shuns demagoguery on his race to power and who practices decency and probity in his personal and professional life.
The results were devastating for me, a liberal humanist by education and training, who recognizes the value of a human being as an individual and his right to liberty and happiness.  Modi did not fit into my idea of a leader; neither did Rahul nor Kejriwall. I began to lose faith in our democracy as it had failed to find  a person who could be worthy of the founding fathers of  free India- the noble triumvirate of Gandhi-Nehru- Patel. The results stunned me- not that I did not anticipate a Modi Victory nor a return of the NDA to form the government at the Centre- but the rout of the Congress in sync with Modi’s primary goal of establishing a ‘Congress mukht Bharat’.
The article Cultural Revenge by Santosh Desai, appearing three days after the pronouncement of the results is a brilliant analysis of Modi’s triumph over liberal humanism which often seeks  to erase all discriminations against marginalized people and minorities by highlighting the social divisiveness in the context of  class, religion and gender. Liberal humanists champion the cause of the poor and the weak, seeking an inclusive society and cultivating humanity. Modi’s approach in contrast had been to continue with the cultural mainstream and not bring any earthshaking structural changes in society while promising progress to all within that constituency. This had a great appeal to all sections of society as it provided the comfort of ‘social continuity with an ongoing evolutionary change’.  While the analysis is true to the last detail, it certainly raises questions about the validity of liberal humanism that some of us - sneeringly and contemptuously looked down upon as vapid intellectuals-believe in. Liberal humanism encourages critical thinking and evidence (rationalism, empiricism) over established doctrine or faith (fideism). It is also aligned with secularism and espouses  ‘reason, ethics, and social and economic justice, and makes a plea  for science to replace dogma and the supernatural as the basis of morality and decision-making’(Nicolas Walter).But unfortunately, it is today wrongly perceived as a concept of negation of all social structures and religious faiths that form the basis of cultural mainstream. In this hour of Modi’s  triumph, Santosh Desai’s article has  given me the strength   to voice my views on liberal humanism and its responsibility to human governance which  is inclusionary and does not exclude any person by reason of his faith, religion, caste and class.
The boldness to break free of my self- imposed withdrawal and silence was further inspired by GopalKrishna Gandhi’s open letter to Mr.Modi.  In it he voices forth the fears of 69% of the  population who did not vote for Modi’s  BJP even though with just 31% vote share the party had gained humungous majority in the new Parliament.  Mr.Gandhi( truly belonging to the family of the Mahatma) requests Modi to eschew the language of uniformism when speaking to a republic of pluralism,  and give up the vocabulary of “oneness” to an imagination of many-nesses that is special to our nation of such vast diversity. In a statesmanlike address, he advises Modi  to ‘requite the applause of your support-base but, equally, redeem the trust of those who have not supported you … and ‘be Maharana Pratap in your struggle as you conceive it, but be an Akbar in your repose. Be a Savarkar in your heart, if you must, but be an Ambedkar in your mind. Be an RSS-trained believer in Hindutva in your DNA, if you need to be, but be the Wazir-e-Azam of Hindostan that the 69 per cent who did not vote for you, would want you to be.’
 The third article- though it was the first among these three to find a place in the newspaper is by Abhishek Singhvi who talks about the possible reforms that Congress should undertake to regain its lost position. Though I do not wish to enumerate on all those suggestions such as full use of talents available in both the old and the young members of the Congress-that is, merging age with experience, to remain vigilant and wary of rainbow coalition and steer clear of the opportunistic alliances , to encourage the growth of strong leadership at the state level and grass root level etc, I wish to add the most important reform- to give up the party’s crutches on one family. If any of the family member displays qualities of leadership to resuscitate the party, s/he or should be welcomed. Anyone who aspires to be a leader should rise up on her/his merit and not on primogenital rights. This will save the party from charges of dynasty rule and incompetence to boot. If Rahul has failed to deliver on three occasions- in Bihar, UP and in the national elections, to insulate him from attack is going in for another self goal. If Priyanka can show verve and sparkle and has the intelligence to identify and work towards the demands of the new aspirational India, without compromising on inclusive humanism, the party can support her claims to be the leader. Otherwise the party can no longer take umbrage under a banyan tree that does not allow any fresh growth under its shade.
I am emboldened to write this taking cue from three well analyzed pieces of writing. With all modesty, I assert that I am nowhere near the wisdom of GopalKrishna Gandhi, the intellectualism of Santosh Desai and the searing honesty of Abhishek Sighvi.  I write because I feel impelled to write and voice forth my concern  for the survival of Liberal humanism, of the unity and integrity of the nation and of Congress –if not for any other reason, at least for providing good opposition without which democracy will die a slow and certain death.

Thursday, 15 May 2014

Exit Polls



 (In a hurry to catch the post before the bugle is sounded for the Victory of the modern Messiah)

The exit polls have generated high decibel euphoric cry shattering the 48 hour silence preceding the last phase of 2014 Indian elections and announcing the triumph of Modi, the new Messaiah and his one-man year-long campaign to banish the Congress forever from the face of India.. All news channels have come with their exit poll findings and the difference among their calculations is  marginal while  giving an outright victory to BJP to emerge as the single party with the largest majority. What is left for the 16th (the d-day for the announcement of the results) though every channel advertises its exclusive coverage of the poll results? The channels await the results only to see how far they can pat themselves for their accuracy in predicting Modi’s victory. It will be  Breaking News  all through the day followed by a marathon talk session among the studio panelists whose words of wisdom will be lost in the din that the Breaking News will let loose. The candidates will wait to see the margin of their victory or loss, either to burst crackers in this hot mid-summer or to fade far away with their mid-summer day dreams shattered. All of them will be preparing their two liners to speak on the microphone such as a victory of the masses , a victory for change, a victory for Modi, the Messiah, or with pretended humility accepting the verdict of the people. The spin doctors both on the side of the victor and the vanquished will come out either exalting the PM in waiting and singing paeans to him or wondering how their right party lost to wrong reasons. The voters will wait to congratulate themselves for holding the democratic  power in their hands to shape the destiny of the poll players.  They will have to wait for another five years or in the losers lament only for less than a couple of years to exercise their power to make or mar  the politicians..
With exit polls signaling a Modi victory, can the Congress dare hope for a modicum of success? The Modi acolytes  instead of remaining euphoric in victory have started feeling sorry for the vanquished for trusting  the ma-beta-beti combine for its ruination. They are actually doing the analysis for the poor Congress ,who according to them now stand orphaned as the  ma-beta-beti-jamaibabu combine will be banished  to wilderness in  Kandava prastha. The Modi-ites in all magnanimity tell the poor Congis ‘abandon all hope, you who enter the poll fray’ as no Arjun is  in sight to save you. In the same breath they add: ‘abandon all despair; the Messiah is on the throne’.  The tweets from Modi  votaries are less about their party and more about the missing prince of the Congress at his Mom’s farewell party to the good old man whose only virtuous sin was obedience to  her and  about how the intellect of  the Oxford educated economist was blunted by  Madam and how the aristocracy of the  duo -dynasty will henceforth be replaced by a single man and his oligarchy of ‘yes ministers’.
At the end of all this euphoric slanging on the TV sets and twitter sites as a prelude to the march of the Messiah into 7 RCR, a wimpish question arises within me what if exit polls are belied! Well with just 15 hours to go before the dance of democracy begins on the TV studios, will I be left alive to witness it or marauded and butchered for uttering a blasphemy against the modern Messiah!

Sunday, 11 May 2014

The Sound of Silence



                                                               The Sound of Silence
The guns will fall silent at least for the next two days. The last phase of election is scheduled for the 12th and so there will be a semblance of silence for two days from the political cacophony of the last few weeks. After the 12th there will be mayhem as all the TV channels and newspapers will come up with their exit polls. I wonder how they will cope with this 2-dayimposition of silence on election rhetoric. For the past so many days, weeks and months, ever since Narendra Modi was nominated as the PM candidate by the RSS-BJP combine, our ears have been deafened by words that have been in every sense a stain on silence. Most of the words were empty rhetoric, again a stain on nothingness that is characteristic of our existence. The acrimonious debates on TV with party spokespersons outshouting each other had left the audience clueless to what was being shouted. For the first time even the saas-bahu soaps were preferred to the wordy fights on the television as they were less noisy with only one character holding forth at any point of time to the silence of others.
We all know about the argumentative nature of We, the Indians. Though Professor Amartya Sen looks at it as a positive quality that keeps democracy alive, there is no parallel in the world to our loquacity and garrulousness. We are never good conversationalists as we prefer to engage in soliloquies than discussions. We try to score points in arguments by verbosity expressed at the top of our voice. If noise pollution index is drawn, we will take the pride of place. Similarly we can claim to top any chart for verbosity. Whatever we say can be said in half the number of words we use. While the political leaders take the cake for volubility, the worst offenders are some of the anchors who make an exhibition of their profound wisdom and knowledge on all issues under the sun and loudly pontificate through a wordy express at a speed of 300 words per minute. Their preamble and their questions take most of the question hour of the tele-debates, leaving very little time for the questioned to give an answer which s/he will gamely attempt in full throated volume with long winded sentences. This voluble exercise will be aborted mid-way as the anchor turns to the next person to reply (not before indulging in yet another long intervention on the issue discussed). The way these anchors scissor the replies of their hapless victims reminds me of the famed Tirupati barbers who will flit from one half tonsured head to another to ensure their maximum income when the tonsure is finally complete for all the heads.
Hence this reprieve from the word duel for at least a meagre 48 hours is a welcome rest from the drumming our ears had received all this while. Every politician desiring to score brownie points has come out with statements which according to them are true to the last letter. The pity is that most of us do not understand the truth that none of us ever speak the whole truth. Our words are always conditioned by those whom we address and whose assent we seek. The question is what is truth and what is falsehood? It is naive to say that which is factual or information of facts is the truth. The concept of integral truth- as the whole truth and nothing but the truth is an ideal that is best propagated in a court room. But our use of language is always intentional and depends on the audience to whom it is addressed. To claim that we speak only the truth is itself a falsehood as our communication is never free from being motivational. George Steiner writes: ‘We speak less than the truth, we fragment in order to reconstruct desired alternatives, we select and elide. It is not ‘the things which are’, but those which might be, which we would bring about, which the eye and the remembrance compose...the shallow cascade of mendacity which attends my refusal of a boring dinner engagement is not the same thing as the un-saying of history and lives in a Stalinist Encyclopaedia.’  So when the politicians and anchors keep shouting at each other and shouting into our ears, we should realize that they are all engaged in speaking half truths and quarter truths –just enough to tilt the balance of our response in their favour.
It is true that words are all we have and we are genetically wired to thoughts that seek an outlet through words. But we need silence to recover our thoughts, to sustain us amidst verbal onslaught we are subjected to, to preserve our sanity and to nourish our wisdom. The sound of silence speaks far more than the sound of words. Buddha succinctly hails silence and says ‘ Silence is an empty space, space is the home of the awakened mind.’  Let us be thankful to the Election Commission for enabling us to listen to the sounds of silence, distinct from the verbal onslaught that has gone on far too long.
PS:
You may wonder why I do not keep silent The answer is what my favourite writer has said :'there is nothing to express, nothing with which to express, nothing from which to express, no power to express, no desire to express, together with the obligation to express.’
Hence this writing on the sound of silence.



Sunday, 4 May 2014

The Existential Chakravyuha



                                                       The Existential Chakravyuha
The German philosopher Martin Heidegger describes individual human existence as ‘Geworfenheit’ or ‘thrownness’ to express the arbitrary and inscrutable nature of being thrown into this world.  The word Geworfenheit signifies ‘the matter-of-fact character of human finitude’ that begins with human beings arbitrarily ‘thrown-in’ to the world and ends with  similar arbitrariness of being ‘thrown-out’ of the world and the compulsion thereof to be  in continuous engagement with the world. This projection into, and engagement with, a personal world is a never-ending process of involvement with the world as mediated through projection of one’s self.
In one sense each one of us from our birth is thrown into a Chakravyuha and like the epic young hero Abhimanyu, does not know to come out of it. Our existential chakravyuha consists of concentric circles of relatives, friends and acquaintances that keep rotating clockwise and anti clockwise and makes it difficult to penetrate through the circular rings to get out. Thus through our entire lifespan we remain incarcerated within the circles. Chakravyuha thus represents the character of human finitude. Given the inalterable facts of thrownness and caught in a chakravyuha, our options are limited to circulating around the multi-layer formation till such time when we get fully engulfed and fall down. Life is nothing but a spinning death machine. But it is given to every individual to battle his/her way through the concentric rings and seek the infinite that is beyond. Though there are no statistics available as to how many penetrated beyond the chakravyuha and reached the blissful( so it is told) infinite, the presence of countless number of people in this world testifies to our singular failure to cross the  Rubicon. This following quote from Samuel Beckett’s Waiting for Godot confirms the increasing number of people hemmed in by the circular rings.
                             The tears of the world are a constant quantity. For each one who begins to weep    somewhere else another stops. The same is true of the laugh. Let us not then speak ill of our generation, it is not any unhappier than its predecessors. Let us not speak well of it either. Let us not speak of it at all. It is true the population has increased.-
So the question arises as to what is to be done trapped as we are in the existential and eternal chakravyuha. It is futile and foolish to attempt breaking it and getting out. Even Abhimanyu, Arjuna’ son and Krishna’s nephew failed. The only difference is Abhimanyu entered the chakravyuha while we have been thrown into it. Abhimanyu died fighting valiantly while we await a pathetic and unheroic death.
Given the facticity of thrownness and being-in-existence, (geworfenheit and dasein) what are our limited options? The concentric rings of which ‘I’ or the individual is at the centre comprise those of family, friends and acquaintances which include the good, the bad and the indifferent. There are other spherical rings spinning around the common centre that comprise society, community, nation and the world. Pets, beasts, animals and other beings have also their own habitats within these spherical rings that are in constant motion. Willy nilly we individually have to live with the different sets of inhabitants who revolve round us. The first ring – that of family is a ‘given’. No one can claim to choose or design the family into which s/he is thrown. We are born into a family without having a say in the selection. The second is that of those we choose-persons we know, we like and we trust. It is a choice we consciously make and not a choice that is imposed on us. If we select friends under pressure, the ring cannot hold them for long. They will be relegated to the third and the largest ring of acquaintances. Similarly those who become intimate and for whom there is mutual regard, liking, affection, and loyalty move with ease into the first ring as though they belong to the ‘given’ circle. The second ring is made up of personal relationships formed at different periods in our lives outside of home and they have a staying power that is more than that of the family. The personal bonding among friends, though not genetic , has stronger roots as it results from shared emotional , intellectual and spiritual experiences. The last circle represents acquaintances- persons acquired by a relationship less intimate than friendship. These relationships are social and professional and acquired for a variety of reasons. The definition of acquaintance as given by Ambrose Bierce in The Devil's Dictionary is a person whom we know well enough to borrow from, but not well enough to lend to. It works both ways as the acquaintance will also be interested in borrowing rather than lending. This exchange, if profitable makes for good acquaintances, if tricky, it results in enmity and if neutral, it becomes indifferent. This is the largest circle as we come across a very large number of persons daily - while in schools and colleges, in office as professional colleagues, or in our day to day dealings at home and outside of home.  We cannot ignore this circle as it thrusts itself on us whether we like it or not.
Can we break free of these rings within rings and step out from the centre? More pertinent is the question as to why do we want to break free as we are not programmed to live in isolation. Even a little bird wants to break free from the secure hideout inside the nest. It waits impatiently to take wings. Every growing adolescent tries to break free of the family to establish his/her identity, but only to realize that the second and the third ring close in on him and deny him his freedom to live on his own.  This is the existential paradox that is succinctly encapsulated in Rousseau’s comment in his The Social Contract that ‘Man was born free, and everywhere he is in chains’. Being-in- existence is to be within the confines of the chakravyuha comprising friends and foes, relatives and kin groups. As each of these circular formations rotates simultaneously in opposite directions, it is impossible to escape confinement within them.  In other words the concentric circles rotate in adherence to rules and laws codified by family, society, community, nation and the world. Often these codes conflict with each other and demand dutiful obedience to them. The freedom to be an individual with rights to his/her own living clashes with the duties imposed by the different denizens of the rings, giving rise to the unresolvable problem of how to subordinate the individual good to that of the community or society in which s/he has to move. The fact of being thrown into this world  denies one the freedom to be an individual and forces him/her to be a part of the society or community , a citizen of a nation and then by extension a citizen of the world. No one can break free of this chakravyuha. Wisdom lies in accepting chakravyuha as the ‘given’ and organize one’s life to stay within it by striking a balance between right to freedom and duty to those with whom one is engaged. 
This is the essential paradox of all human existence:  can we humans simultaneously live singly and collectively? Is it possible to walk freely without treading on others toes? Can we bring back integrity in our life so that we live? Is it wise to bristle against the charavyuha that has been laid for us from our birth? Can we stay within the chakravyuha and accept life’s spins round and round? It is possible if we restore self integrity as we gyrate through the rings . Given below are a few steps that are easy and practicable:
1. Be authentic with yourself-be aware of your full range of thoughts and feelings and live true to them
2. Find what is it that interests you and that you can do well, and when you find it, put your whole soul into it-every bit of energy, ambition and your natural ability.
3. Be authentic with others. Assume responsibility for every one of your actions that will impact others. Always be truthful in all your relationship. Develop empathy and compassion and become a channel for good.
4. Consciously create a circle of authenticity around yourself both within the family and outside of home. This is possible by consciously looking at what you can do to make your situation better and make your relationships in the family and in the workplace more meaningful.
The following words of Buddha sum up all the above listed efforts towards achieving integrity in life:
                                    The thought manifests as the word;
                                     The word manifests as the deed;
                                     The deed develops into habit;
                                     And habit hardens into character.
                                     So watch the thought and its ways with care,
                                     And let it spring from love
                                     Born out of concern for all beings.